Protective behavior against personalized ads: Motivation to turn personalization off

Abstract

Data collection and processing for personalized advertising has become a common practice in the industry. For this reason, regulators have been aiming to empower consumers to exercise more control over their data. Companies that collect and process data for personalized advertising are required to be transparent and among others, provide consumers with technical knowledge about the personalization process. At the same time, they have started offering settings to withdraw consent for processing data for personalization purposes by opting out from personalized advertising. However, such opt-out functions remain mostly unused. Thus, this study investigates first, if technical knowledge about personalization empowers consumers to use such opt-out functions and second, what mechanisms can explain the empowering impact of knowledge. Drawing on Rogers’ (1975) protection motivation theory (PMT) and applying an innovative combination of traditional (online experiment, N = 425, Mage = 48) and computational (online behavior tracking, N = 80, Mage = 48) research methods, the study shows that technical knowledge has no empowering effect on consumers by indirectly lowering opt-out motivation and behavior. The results also demonstrate that perceived severity and response efficacy increase motivation to opt-out, while positive attitude towards personalization and perceived self-efficacy lower it. Being one of the first studies to apply PMT to personalization context and computational methods to measure opt-out, it offers several important societal and theoretical implications regarding consumer empowerment and personalized advertising online.

How Social Cues in Virtual Assistants Influence Concerns and Persuasion: The Role of Voice and a Human Name

“…This provides a new level of insight into theories on persuasion knowledge 16 and ''hidden'' persuasion. [17][18][19] Although giving a name to an assistant leads users to see through the persuasive intent of a recommendation, it does not protect them against being persuaded. This is contrary to the traditional idea that more persuasion knowledge leads to less persuasion.…”

“…17 As people have less experience with receiving persuasive messages via voice-controlled devices than via screens, they are, therefore, likely to be less aware that a recommendation is, in reality, a persuasive attempt. 14,16,18 People's concerns and persuasion knowledge may subsequently influence the extent to which they are persuaded by recommendations made via an assistant. Previous research has demonstrated that awareness of persuasion attempts usually leads to more critical evaluation among adults, but not among young consumers.…”

The algorithmic persuasion framework in online communication: conceptualization and a future research agenda

“…A second method is the use of a custom-built browser plug-in designed to collect participants' online interactions and behaviors (e.g., Bodo et al, 2017;Haim and Nienierza, 2019;Strycharz et al, 2019). This approach has also been referred to as "data donation" (Krafft et al, 2019).…”

Consumer response to podcast advertising: the interactive role of persuasion knowledge and parasocial relationships

“…The growing intrusiveness of digital marketing has led to the development of more advanced attitudinal and behavioral coping tactics among consumers. For example, consumer concerns about online data privacy have led to new coping behaviors, such as setting up filters to withdraw consent for delivery of personalized advertising (Strycharz et al , 2019), installing ad blockers on computers and mobile devices to block all ads (Brinson and Britt, 2021) and unpairing wearable devices from smart phone applications to avoid third party data tracking and advertising (Brinson and Rutherford, 2020).…”