Intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) in proteins can
undergo
liquid–liquid phase separation (LLPS) for functional assembly,
but this increases the chance of forming disease-associated amyloid
fibrils. Not all amyloid fibrils form through LLPS however, and the
importance of LLPS relative to other pathways in fibril formation
remains unclear. We investigated this question in TDP-43, a motor
neuron disease and dementia-causing protein that undergoes LLPS, using
thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence, NMR, transmission electron microscopy
(TEM), and wide-angle X-ray scattering (WAXS) experiments. Using a
fluorescence probe modified from ThT strategically designed for targeting
protein assembly rather than β-sheets and supported by TEM images,
we propose that the biphasic ThT signals observed under LLPS-favoring
conditions are due to the presence of amorphous aggregates. These
aggregates represent an intermediate state that diverges from the
direct pathway to β-sheet-dominant fibrils. Under non-LLPS conditions
in contrast (at low pH or at physiological conditions in a construct
with key LLPS residues removed), the protein forms a hydrogel. Real-time
WAXS data, ThT signals, and TEM images collectively demonstrate that
the gelation process circumvents LLPS and yet still results in the
formation of fibril-like structural networks. We suggest that the
IDR of TDP-43 forms disease-causing amyloid fibrils regardless of
the formation pathway. Our findings shed light on why both LLPS-promoting
and LLPS-inhibiting mutants are found in TDP-43-related diseases.