Objectives
Develop and validate short and rapid forms of the 36-item Menstrual
Practice Needs Scale (MPNS-36).
Design
Item reduction prioritised content validity and was informed by
cognitive interviews with schoolgirls in Bangladesh, performance of
scale items in past research and stakeholder feedback. The original
MPNS-36 was revalidated, and short and rapid forms tested in a
cross-sectional survey. This was followed by further tests of
dimensionality, internal consistency and validity in multiple
cross-sectional surveys.
Setting and participants
Short form (MPNS-SF) and rapid form (MPNS-R) measures were developed
in a survey of 313 menstruating girls (mean age=13.51) in Khulna,
Bangladesh. They were further tested in the baseline survey of the
Adolescent Menstrual Experiences and Health Cohort, in Khulna,
Bangladesh (891 menstruating girls, mean age=12.40); and the dataset
from the MPNS-36 development in Soroti, Uganda (538 menstruating girls,
mean age=14.49).
Results
The 18-item short form reflects the six original subscales, with the
four core subscales demonstrating good fit in all three samples (Khulna
pilot: root mean square error of approximation (RMSEA)=0.064, 90% CI
0.043 to 0.084, Comparative Fit Index (CFI)=0.94, Tucker-Lewis Index
(TLI)=0.92. Cohort baseline: RMSEA=0.050, 90% CI 0.039 to 0.062,
CFI=0.96, TLI=0.95. Uganda: RMSEA=0.039, 90% CI 0.028 to 0.050,
CFI=0.95, TLI=0.94). The 9-item rapid form captures diverse needs. A
two-factor structure was the most appropriate but fell short of adequate
fit (Khulna pilot: RMSEA=0.092, 90% CI 0.000 to 0.158, CFI=0.93,
TLI=0.89). Hypothesised associations between the MPNS scores and other
constructs were comparable between the MPNS-36 and MPNS-SF in all
populations, and replicated, with attenuation, in the MPNS-R. Internal
consistency remained acceptable.
Conclusions
The MPNS-SF offers a reliable and valid measure of adolescent girls’
menstrual hygiene experience while reducing participant burden, to
support implementation and improve measurement in menstrual health
research. The MPNS-R provides a brief measure with poorer structural
validity, suited to short surveys and including menstrual health within
broader research topics.