Li- and Na-ion batteries are effective
energy storage technologies.
Nonetheless, currently used organic-electrolyte batteries present
well-known safety problems. Therefore, the research community is intensively
looking for potential alternatives. Aqueous batteries based on low-cost
salts in water could be an interesting choice since they are safe
and environmentally benign. However, working with aqueous electrolytes
brings new detrimental mechanisms such as proton intercalation. Understanding
the (de)intercalation chemistry of protons and alkali is one of the
keys for designing cathode materials in such aqueous electrochemical
cells. In this work, we carry out density functional theory calculations
to investigate the H+/alkali exchange in layered LiCoO2 and NaCoO2 materials. By computing the grand potential
phase diagram and voltage–composition plots, we determine the
relative stability of several orderings of protons, alkali, and vacancies.
The fully protonated CoO2 lattice (CoO(OH)) is revealed
to be the most stable insertion product due to the formation of interlayer
hydrogen bonds. Our computations demonstrate the key role of layer
stacking: H+ insertion is favored in prismatic (P) stacking,
while Li favors octahedral (O) stacking. While the fully protonated
layered cobalt oxide is the thermodynamically favored product when
protons and alkali compete, we show that mixing protons and lithium
is energetically disfavored because of the different stacking preferences.
We suggest that the kinetic difficulty in nucleating fully protonated
phases in the layered oxide prevents proton insertion when cycling
LiCoO2 in an aqueous electrolyte. The good cyclability
and lack of proton insertion in LiCoO2 are, therefore,
a result of the slow kinetics of protonation in partially lithiated
cobalt oxide. On the other hand, we demonstrate that NaCoO2 is prone to proton and alkali mixing due to the different stacking
preferences for sodium. We hypothesize that this could lead to proton
intercalation and poor performances in aqueous batteries for NaCoO2 cathodes.