Retronychia is an increasingly known cause of paronychia. It was classically regarded as an indication for total nail plate avulsion, but recent case series have questioned the real need for this approach. In order to establish a proper recommendation for patients presenting with retronychia, we retrospectively reviewed all articles with retronychia case reports. Total nail plate avulsion is still the most efficient treatment option. Topical steroids and other noninvasive approaches can be useful in some early, mild cases, but further prospective studies are needed in order to access their efficacy.