The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends comprehensive assessments for children entering foster care. These children may be placed with biological parents, kin, or in nonrelative foster care. It is not known whether health-related needs differ by placement. Chart abstractions were conducted of child welfare and medical records of 1542 children, ages 3 months to 5 years 11 months, admitted to San Diego's sole emergency shelter/receiving facility from April 1, 1998, through June 30, 1999, for investigation of alleged maltreatment. Children were discharged to three placement types: biological parents (28.5%), kinship caregivers (28.4%), or nonrelative foster parents (43.1%), Overall, 86.7% of children studied demonstrated physical, developmental, or mental health needs, with more than half displaying two or more problems. More than half of the children had a "Suspect" score on the Denver-II; 70.3% of children with "Suspect" scores were found to have delay on a development evaluation. Almost one tenth of the sample were diagnosed with one or more mental health conditions. Few differences were found for physical, developmental, or mental health concerns by placement. Results suggest that young children placed with biological parents or in kinship care have similar needs to those of children placed with foster parents. This study confirms the importance of comprehensive assessments for young children removed from their homes, regardless of placement. It also illustrates a need for standardized assessment criteria, particularly for developmental and mental health status, and for collaborative care models for all young children entering the child welfare system, regardless of their placement following investigation.
Index termsfoster care; child welfare; developmental delay; mental health; physical healthThe estimated 826,000 children currently served by the child welfare/child protective services system 1 (hereafter termed child welfare) are more susceptible to poor health outcomes than any other subpopulation of youth in the United States. These children are removed from their homes when parents are unable to care for them due to prenatal drug/alcohol exposure, abuse, neglect, and/or violence. These background risk factors predispose these children to a myriad of physical, developmental, and mental health problems. Infants and toddlers, who are dependent on the care of others during a critical phase of brain development, 2-5 are especially vulnerable to both the experience and consequences of maltreatment 6-9 and are the most rapidly expanding age group entering child welfare. 3,10 Overall, the largest age group in child welfare (30%) is composed of children younger than 5 years of age. 1 Out-of-home placement can compound these problems if services are not provided effectively. Recent federal amendments to the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) in 2003 recommend that states enhance collaboration among public health agencies, child welfare, and community programs to address the comprehensive...