Objective The aim of this study was to conduct an in-depth survey of the psychiatric care provided for medically ill older adults in general hospitals in New Zealand (NZ). Method As part of a larger survey of Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry (CLP) services for all ages in NZ (CLPSNZ-2), a 44-question survey was emailed to clinicians who were involved in providing psychiatric care for medically ill older adults at each of the 16 general hospitals with designated CLP services. Results Responses were obtained from 22 services at 16 hospitals – 14 CLP services and eight Psychiatry of Old Age (POA) in-reach services. These services were found to be under-resourced, operate with highly variable service models, and predominantly provide inpatient consultations. Services could be conceptualised as six prototypes with variations of POA in-reach to hospitals, scope of CLP cover and collaboration between services. Conclusion The heterogeneity in the psychiatric care for medically ill older adults in NZ means that there is an urgent need to develop more consistent CLP service models that better serve the specialist needs of older adults, and establish the policies, resources and standards needed to support them.