Psychopharmacological Drugs as Represented in the Press: Results of Systematic Analysis of Newspapers and Popular Magazines

Abstract

The representation of mental diseases and psychopharmacological drugs in the media, especially in the press, is thought to be of great impact on people's opinions on the subject. During the course of one year, all articles about psychopharmacological drugs and cardiac drugs published in nineteen German newspapers were collected. All statements, together with related aspects, reasons for prescription, individual details of the patient, effects and side-effects, were registered and classified according to a key. The results show that, in contrast to 13% of the articles about cardiac drugs, half of the reports about psychopharmacological drugs deal primarily with the problems of side-effects and dependence the drugs may produce. There was much more critical comment and emotional emphasis used to characterize the psychopharmacological drugs. Only in 9% of articles was their therapeutic efficacy mentioned. Cardiac drugs are generally discussed objectively in a medical context and in 53% efficacy is emphasized. Psychopharmacological drugs are often mentioned in stories about prominent persons having a life crisis, taking drugs, turning to alcoholism, or in the context of social decline. Only in 3% of all articles about psychopharmacological drugs was it possible to identify a serious mental disease as the reason for prescription. The reasons for and implications of these findings, which mainly reflect the negatively biased image of psychopharmacological drugs in women's magazines (while they are treated relatively fairly in general newspapers) are discussed.

What do popular Spanish women's magazines say about caesarean section? A 21‐year survey

“…For example, half of the reports on mental diseases and psychopharmacological drugs in German magazines were incomplete or negatively biased. 30 Similarly, cancer coverage in 309 issues of Canadian women's magazines did not reflect the contribution of cancer as a cause of death in Canadian women. 25…”

Atitudes de profissionais de saúde mental em relação a indivíduos com esquizofrenia: uma comparação transcultural entre Suíça e Brasil

“…That finding coincides with MH professionals' personal reluctance to take antipsychotics themselves in the case of a psychotic disorder 32 or with the negative perception of psychopharmacological treatment in general 33,34 . Interestingly, such distrust against psychotropic treatment closely corresponds with the negative picture drawn by newspaper reports 35,36 .…”

Drogas e saúde na imprensa brasileira: uma análise de artigos publicados em jornais e revistas

“…Esse dado é um indicador do quanto o discurso sobre drogas recebe o tom "emocional" nos mais diferentes setores da sociedade. No entanto, essa ênfase não parece ser peculiaridade das drogas ilícitas na imprensa brasileira, sendo observada para os psicotrópicos em geral, inclusive medicamentos, também em outros países (Hillert et al, 1996).…”