Postictal psychosis is a rare but potentially serious complication in patients with seizure disorders. There is no consensus on best practices in managing and treating postictal psychosis as well as other psychoses of epilepsy, but current research is investigating topics such as adherence to seizure medications and antipsychotic administration during or before psychosis and addressing psychosocial stressors as potential components of effective treatment. We present a case report detailing a patient's lengthy history of postictal psychosis due to her underlying temporal lobe epilepsy; her disease course as correlated by a diagnostic electroencephalogram (EEG), her history of medication nonadherence, and the treatment of postictal psychosis are also discussed.