Publication trends in obstructive sleep apnea: Evidence of need for more evidence

Abstract

ObjectivePublished research in obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) appears limited despite OSA being a highly prevalent adult and pediatric disease leading to many adverse outcomes if left untreated. We aimed to quantify the deficit in OSA scientific literature in order to provide a novel way of identifying gaps in knowledge and a need for further research inquiry.MethodsThis was a Bibliometric analysis study. Using Ovid Medline database we analyzed and compared research output (medical and surgical) between adult OSA and similarly prevalent chronic conditions (Type II diabetes (T2DM), coronary artery disease (CAD) and osteoarthritis (OA)) from December 2016 up to fifty years prior. Linear graphs were utilized to trend collected data. Utilizing same strategy, we compared publication trends for pediatric OSA to asthma and gastroesophageal reflux (GER).ResultsAdult OSA publications (n = 9314) were significantly underrepresented when compared to T2DM (n = 66,023), CAD (n = 31,526) and OA (n = 34,123). Linear plots demonstrated that despite increasing number of publications this disparity persisted annually. Surgical literature composed 10.4% (n = 972) of adult OSA publications and reached a plateau in the last ten years. Pediatric OSA (n = 2994) had less research output when compared to asthma (n = 47,442) and GER (n = 6705). However, over past five years pediatric OSA surpassed GER in annual number of publications. Surgical literature represented 23.1% (n = 693) of pediatric OSA publications and continued increasing over past ten years. Study methodologies for both adult and pediatric OSA showed a lack of randomized controlled trials and meta-analyses in comparison to other diseases.ConclusionOur review shows substantial deficit in total, annual and surgical adult OSA published research compared to similarly prevalent diseases. This trend is not entirely observed in pediatric OSA literature.

Prevalence of Pulmonary Hypertension in Pediatric Patients With Obstructive Sleep Apnea and a Cardiology Evaluation: A Retrospective Analysis

“…Reliable and accurate prevalence estimates of PH in children with OSA will allow for improved resource allocation and health care planning. 34…”

Clinical Trials in Obstructive Sleep Apnea: Recognizing Trends and Future Opportunities

“…However, it is unclear what the clinical landscape of OSA research is at present. A recent publication by Araslanova et al demonstrated that adult OSA research publications are significantly underrepresented when compared to other chronic medical conditions such as coronary artery disease, diabetes mellitus, and osteoarthritis. OSA had significantly fewer randomized controlled trials and meta‐analyses when compared to these other conditions.…”

A bibliometric analysis of obstructive sleep apnea and anesthesia

“…[28] In the pediatric population, the prevalence of OSA is between 1 and 6% in all children and 59% in obese children. [29] There is a high risk of perioperative complications. Among 111 pediatric tonsillectomy cases, 57% of children with death or near-death events met the criteria for being at risk for OSA, and apnea was observed in 46% of these patients.…”