Publicity vs. Advertising in a Cluttered Environment: Effects on Attention and Brand Identification

Abstract

The cluttered environment of most marketing communications poses a major challenge. PR is often suggested to break through clutter in a way that advertising does not; by being part of the editorial content, publicity should get more attention than comparable ads. Based on advertising clutter research, we argue that advertising will have an advantage over publicity in gaining attention and ensuring brand identification. An empirical study of publicity and advertising embedded in actual newspapers is presented in support of this argument. Additional studies and better PR evaluation practices are called for, and implications for familiar and unfamiliar brands are discussed.

The blog and the bountiful: Exploring the effects of disguised product placement on blogs that are revealed by a third party

“…Rosengren 2008). That development has not gone unnoticed by brand managers, companies are scrambling to find new ways of communicating.…”

The Effects of Guerilla Marketing on Gen Y’s Purchase Intention — A Study in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam

“…The frequency of using the Internet supported [7] and [8], confirming that Internet has been a vital marketing tool for company when people have been using it more frequently than ever. Frequency of advertisements exposure also reinforced the way advertising leads to high literacy of the audience and negative attitudes towards promotional messages when there was advertising clutter [10], [14], [15].…”

“…Online advertising has developed into the fastest growing type with its tremendous promotional contents [8]. However, the proliferation of advertisements leads to problems of advertising clutter [9], which reduces consumer attention to promotional messages [10], [11], impact negatively consumer attitude towards the ads [12], and reduces memorability of the ad and the promoted brand [13]. Also, the audiences themselves have higher literacy because of exposing too much to advertisements.…”

Utilisation du réseau Facebook dans une campagne de prévention pour jeunes adolescents : analyse secondaire des données d’une étude postcampagne

“…En concentrant nos efforts sur ces enjeux, on risque cependant de perdre de vue le fait qu'une publicité n'existe sans être soutenue inancièrement, produite et ultimement diffusée vers son public. Un public qui évolue dans un univers caractérisé par un encombrement publicitaire sans précédent (Randolph et Viswanath, 2004;Rosengren, 2008). Une compréhension globale de la publicité sociale peut dificilement être réduite à l'observation de certaines de ses composantes.…”