Pulse Rate Variability in Emergency Physicians During Shifts: Pilot Cross-Sectional Study

Abstract

Background The high prevalence of physician burnout, particularly in emergency medicine, has garnered national attention in recent years. Objective means of measuring stress while at work can facilitate research into stress reduction interventions, and wearable photoplethysmography (PPG) technology has been proposed as a potential solution. However, the use of low-burden wearable biosensors to study training and clinical practice among emergency physicians (EP) remains untested. Objective This pilot study aimed to (1) determine the feasibility of recording on-shift photoplethysmographic data from EP, (2) assess the quality of these data, and (3) calculate standard pulse rate variability (PRV) metrics from the acquired dataset and examine patterns in these variables over the course of an academic year. Methods A total of 21 EP wore PPG biosensors on their wrists during clinical work in the emergency department during a 9-hour shift. Recordings were collected during the first quarter of the academic year, then again during the fourth quarter of the same year for comparison. The overall rate of usable data collection per time was computed. Standard pulse rate (PR) and PRV metrics from these two time points were calculated and entered into Student t tests. Results More than 400 hours of data were entered into these analyses. Interpretable data were captured during 8.54% of the total recording time overall. In the fourth quarter of the academic year compared with the first quarter, there was no significant difference in median PR (75.8 vs 76.8; P=.57), mean R-R interval (0.81 vs 0.80; P=.32), SD of R-R interval (0.11 vs 0.11; P=.93), root mean square of successive difference of R-R interval (0.81 vs 0.80; P=.96), low-frequency power (3.5×103 vs 3.4×103; P=.79), high-frequency power (8.5×103 vs 8.3×103; P=.91), or low-frequency to high-frequency ratio (0.42 vs 0.41; P=.43), respectively. Power estimates for each of these tests exceeded .90. A secondary analysis of the resident-only subgroup similarly showed no significant differences over time, despite power estimates greater than .80. Conclusions Although the use of PPG biosensors to record real-time physiological data from EP while providing clinical care seems operationally feasible, this study fails to support the notion that such an approach can efficiently provide reliable estimates of metrics of interest. No significant differences in PR or PRV metrics were found at the end of the year compared with the beginning. Although these methods may offer useful applications to other domains, it may currently have limited utility in the contexts of physician training and wellness.

Persuasive Design Techniques and App Design Recommendations to Improve Health Workforce Capability in Rural Health Professionals: What Do Users Want and How Does an App Help?

“…Although using wearables to measure work performance and stress levels at work has potential [ 26 ], it is still in its infancy. A 2019 randomized controlled trial showed that using wearables to improve emergency physicians’ well-being through monitoring their pulse rate while at work was feasible but not recommended [ 27 ]. The authors found that the biosensor could not provide reliable estimates of metrics of interest in their study context.…”

Psychological Effects of Heart Rate and Physical Vibration on the Operation of Construction Machines: Experimental Study

“…These results provide compelling evidence for physicians, especially those who routinely perform surgical medical duties under tight time constraints, to assess their own stress. The widespread use of objective and ecologically valid measures of stress might provide important clues for understanding and reducing the psychological burden of stressful situations [ 32 ].…”

“…There are several widely accepted HRV metrics [ 32 , 33 ]. HRV measurements are classified into two categories: time-domain measures and frequency-domain measures.…”

Optimizing Wellness in Academic Emergency Medicine

“…Burnout is likely not only related to the stressful stimuli in the ED but also shiftwork-specific conditions. Working in the ED is difficult for the body, though the burden is not entirely understood [94,95]. Rotating shift work is pathological and a recognized disease by the American Academy of Sleep Medicine [96,97].…”