Pushing the Limits of Child Participation in Research: Reflections from a Youth-Driven Participatory Action Research (YPAR) Initiative in Uganda

Abstract

Background: Violence against children (VAC) in Uganda is recognized as an urgent dilemma; however, most research has been quantitatively oriented and has seldom involved children in the research process. Objective: We discuss what we learned about child participation in the research process as a means of informing ethical praxis in future child- and youth-led research initiatives. As an overarching aim of this paper, we utilize our engagement with YPAR as a springboard to reflect on methodological best practices for VAC research that involve children themselves as part of a movement to democratize the research process. Participants and Setting: The study includes street-connected children (40), sexually exploited children (19) and domestic workers (34) in Kampala. Methods: The YPAR team led participant observation, 52 semi-structured life history interviews, 31 auto-photographic exercises, and 4 focus groups. All data collection, analysis and dissemination activities were led by the YPAR team including four Ugandan street-connected youth between the ages of 16–25 and two Ugandan university-trained youth researchers. Results: The results are framed as a methodological reflection regarding the complexities and transformative potential of including children as researchers in the framework of YPAR. Conclusions: We urge scholars to create spaces for sustainable YPAR movements, both in academic and policy arenas, and to design participatory initiatives that prioritize knowledge produced by and for the improvement of children’s lives globally. We encourage challenging traditional, extractive research practices through participatory approaches that carve out spaces for child participation in research.

Game-based Learning and Co-Design with and for Newcomer Children’s Social Adjustment

“…As part of the process, teams shared knowledge, reflected on game-making, and learned through exploration and trying out different options. Our results match the previous literature, which showed the pivotal role of the child as a "process designer," in collaboration with children through designing a PD process Ritterbusch et al, 2020;Schepers, Dreessen, & Zaman, 2018). However, our study…”

Co‐production of health and social science research with vulnerable children and young people: A rapid review

“…Brady et al 27 Lincoln et al 28 Varjavandi 29 Contribute to the choice of research design/method Mitchell et al 30 Ritterbusch et al 31 Gray et al, 23 Nichols and Malenfant 32 Pavarini et al 18 Alderson et al 33 Liddiard et al 34 Develop data collection tools Kelly et al, 35 Noom et al, 36 Taylor et al, 37 Torronen et al 38 Garcia et al 39 Thulien et al 40 Hillier et al, 41 Ritterbusch et al 31 Dadswell et al, 22 Embleton et al, 42 Funk et al, 43 Lam et al, 44 Varjavandi, 29 van Staa et al 45 Liddiard et al 34 Recruitment Lincoln et al 28 Ritterbusch et al 31 Liddiard et al 34 Data collection Brady et al, 27 Curran et al, 46 Kelly et al, 35 Garcia et al, 39 Lincoln et al, 28 Mitchell et al, 30 Hillier et al, 41 Ritterbusch et al, 31 Coser et al, 47 Gray et al, 23 Kramer et al, 48 Lam et al, 44 Nichols and Malenfant, 32 Varjavandi, 29 van Staa et al 45 Chappell et al, 49 Liddiard et al…”

“…Burke et al, 50 Curran et al, 46 Taylor et al, 37 Torronen et al, 38 Garcia et al, 39 Lincoln et al, 28 Mitchell et al 30 Ritterbusch et al 31 Coser et al, 47 Dadswell et al, 22 Funk et al, 43 Kramer et al, 48 Lam et al, 44 Varjavandi 29 Chappell et al, 49 Damian et al 51…”

Children’s narratives on migrant refugees: a practice of global citizenship

“…In traditional research, children are used to provide data. However, a protagonist perspective places children at the centre, transforming research in which the participation of children is fundamental (Ritterbusch et al, 2020), and challenging conventional forms of knowledge construction, support and control that involve children (Cuevas-Parra and Tisdall, 2019). The influence that children have will largely depend on the level and type of participation provided (Fielding, 2012;Hart, 1997;Lundy, 2018).…”