“…Herzog ([18]) and A. Garcia ([17]), and also our results from [19], we show in Proposition 5 that if emb dim(H) < 5, then gr m K[H] is Cohen-Macaulay. It requires a bit more work to prove in Theorem 8 that if emb dim(H) = 5, then gr m K[H] is not Cohen-Macaulay precisely when H is generated as 8, 4u , 4u + 2u , 4u + 2u + u , 6u + 7u + 4u − 8 , or 8, 4u , 4u + 2u , 4u + 2u + 3u , 6u + 9u + 4u − 8 , with u, u , u positive integers and u > 1 is odd.…”