Qualitative mathematical models to support ecosystem‐based management of Australia's Northern Prawn Fishery

Abstract

Abstract. A major decline in the catch of the banana prawn [shrimp], Penaeus (Fenneropenaeus) merguiensis, occurred over a six-year period in the Weipa region of the northeastern Gulf of Carpentaria, Australia. Three main hypotheses have been developed to explain this decline: (1) prawn recruitment collapsed due to overfishing; (2) recruitment collapsed due to a change in the prawn's environment; and (3) adult banana prawns were still present, but fishers could no longer effectively find or catch them. Qualitative mathematical models were used to link population biology, environmental factors, and fishery dynamics to evaluate the alternative hypotheses. This modeling approach provides the means to rapidly integrate knowledge across disciplines and consider alternative hypotheses about how the structure and function of an ecosystem affects its dynamics. Alternative models were constructed to address the different hypotheses and also to encompass a diversity of opinion about the underlying dynamics of the system. Key findings from these analyses are that: instability in the system can arise when discarded fishery bycatch supports relatively high predation pressure; system stability can be enhanced by management of fishing effort or stock catchability; catch per unit effort is not necessarily a reliable indicator of stock abundance; a change in early-season rainfall should affect all stages in the banana prawn's life cycle; and a reduced catch in the Weipa region can create and reinforce a shift in fishing effort away from Weipa. Results from the models informed an approach to test the hypotheses (i.e., an experimental fishing program), and promoted understanding of the system among researchers, management agencies, and industry. The analytical tools developed in this work to address stages of a prawn life cycle and fishery dynamics are generally applicable to any exploited natural resource.

Assessing Different Causes of Crown-of-Thorns Starfish Outbreaks and Appropriate Responses for Management on the Great Barrier Reef

“…Here the links represent processes supporting or leading to each life stage, such as rates of fecundity, survival or mortality. Any number of life stage variables can be accommodated, as long as the overall feedback, or matrix determinant, of the expanded set of life stage variables equals the single variable’s self-effect for the population as a whole [57]. Many of the models also include links representing what are called modified interactions [58], which describe environmental or ecological variables that can regulate the intensity of the interaction of other variables—an example is when a predator’s ability to capture juvenile prey can be reduced if the juvenile prey use coral to escape, thus coral structure modifies (suppresses) the predator‐prey interaction.…”

Identifying potential consequences of natural perturbations and management decisions on a coastal fishery social-ecological system using qualitative loop analysis

“…Loop analysis has been used in a few other cases of scenario analysis in the context of fishery (Anthony et al 2013, EspinozaTenorio et al 2013, Carey et al 2014, Dambacher et al 2015. Nevertheless, this technique presents several limitations that must be carefully addressed in management contexts.…”

The consistency of a species’ response to press perturbations with high food web uncertainty

“…Our analysis focused on a single target species that was embedded within a set of key food web interactions. This kind of intermediate food web module is well suited to loop analysis (Dambacher et al 2015). Yet, it is important to remember that the real food webs that contain walleye are more complex in their entirety than the eight-species webs examined here.…”