Qualitative research in science education: A literature review of current publications

Abstract

This study analyzed articles from the last four years regarding how science education research is framed and discussed as qualitative research. The research question that guided this study was: <i>To what extent do qualitative secondary science teaching research publications reflect high-quality practices found in mainstream methodological texts? </i>The researchers utilized a systematic literature review methodology by (1) creating search terms based on the research question; (2) choosing relevant databases in which to search; (3) conducting the search and gathering articles; and (4) selecting articles based on inclusion criteria. The researchers chose “secondary education” and “science teaching” as search terms relevant to this study. Articles included in the review were peer-reviewed for credibility, available free online as full-text for accessibility, and available in English, which is the authors’ first language. The researchers conducted three levels of screening on the full collection of articles–title, abstract, then methods, to efficiently narrow the large sample of qualitative science education research articles to a manageable and characteristic selection. The findings include that few articles addressed science teaching and learning with deep qualitative engagement. Some articles claimed to use specific qualitative methodologies without adequately expressing aspects of those methodologies, which lend support to the credibility, transferability, dependability, or confirmability of the articles such as the researchers’ subjectivity or member-checking. Those studies that did are indeed diamonds in the ruff.

Navigating Implicit Meanings: The Pragmatic Function of Presuppositions in Communication

“…The impact of presuppositions on human communication is examined in this study using a qualitative methodology. To make conclusions and include their own perspectives in the investigation, qualitative researchers frequently categorized this data by searching for trends (Saldaña, 2013;Stanley & Robertson, 2024). The study looks at real-world instances by combining a survey of the literature with case study analysis.…”

Computational thinking through the lens of biological evolution learning: enhancing understanding through the levels of biological organization and computational complexity

“…The present study used qualitative analysis on student artifacts collected after the computational interventions with the aim of probing more deeply into these relations and to better understand and enhance prior quantitative results (Bryman 2017). Quantitative analysis in science education research is often overshadowed Christensen and Lombardi Evolution: Education and Outreach (2024) 17:10 by quantitative, as it is still favored by many researchers (Stanley and Robertson 2024), yet it may provide unique insight, particularly when done to supplement quantitative analysis (Borrego et al 2009, Eyisi 2016.…”