Quality and safety of in-hospital care for acute medical patients at weekends: a qualitative study

Abstract

BackgroundThe increased mortality risk associated with weekend admission to hospital (the ‘weekend effect’) has been reported across many health systems. More recently research has focused on causal mechanisms. Variations in the organisation and delivery of in-hospital care between weekends and weekdays have been identified, but this is not always to the detriment of weekend admissions, and the impact on mortality is uncertain. The insights of frontline staff and patients have been neglected. This article reports a qualitative study of patients and clinicians, to explore their views on quality and safety of care at weekends.MethodsWe conducted focus groups and interviews with clinicians and patients with experience of acute medical care, recruited from three UK hospital Trusts. We analysed the data using a thematic analysis approach, aided by the use of NVivo, to explore quality and safety of care at weekends.ResultsWe held four focus groups and completed six in-depth interviews, with 19 clinicians and 12 patients. Four threats to quality and safety were identified as being more prominent at weekends, relating to i) the rescue and stabilisation of sick patients; ii) monitoring and responding to deterioration; iii) timely accurate management of the therapeutic pathway; iv) errors of omission and commission.ConclusionsAt weekends patients and staff are well aware of suboptimal staffing numbers, skill mix and access to resources at weekends, and identify that emergency admissions are prioritised over those already hospitalised. The consequences in terms of quality and safety and patient experience of care are undesirable. Our findings suggest the value of focusing on care processes and systems resilience over the weekends, and how these can be better supported, even in the limited resource environment that exists in many hospitals at weekends.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12913-018-3833-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Magnitude and modifiers of the weekend effect in hospital admissions: a systematic review and meta-analysis

“…The paucity of published literature on quantitatively measured patient satisfaction is surprising,37 as patient’s, carer’s, and service provider’s experience must be at the centre of the design and delivery of health services. We will fill in these important evidence gaps through our companion framework synthesis, and other components of the HiSLAC project 94–97…”

Segurança do paciente no ambiente hospitalar: uma revisão integrativa/ Patient safety in the hospital environment: an integrative review

“…Após a leitura dos títulos e resumos foram selecionados 54 para a leitura na íntegra, sendo 24 eleitos para participação desta revisão. Apesar dos resultados encontrados, a literatura sugere que a ciência e a prática da segurança do paciente apresentam uma tendência a focar menos nos danos do passado, obtidos através dos estudos retrospectivos e passou a preocupar-se mais na compreensão dos fatores que apoiam o cuidado seguro e a resiliências dos sistemas e serviços de saúde 13 .…”

Temporal variations in quality of acute stroke care and outcomes in London hyperacute stroke units: a mixed-methods study

“…It is now recognised that temporal variation results, at least in part, from delivery models of care and the cultural values of the health-care sector, enshrined in everyday practice, funding models, staffing practices and wider policies. 29 Recent research, such as the High-Intensity Specialist-Led Acute Care study, 30,31 have taken this approach to examine the intensity of specialist-led care in emergency medical admissions, focusing particularly on the organisation and delivery of care, and medical staffing. 30,31 In the case of urgent stroke care, recent studies have shown that temporal variation in mortality is now decreasing, 32,33 including in London's hyperacute stroke unit (HASU) model.…”

“…29 Recent research, such as the High-Intensity Specialist-Led Acute Care study, 30,31 have taken this approach to examine the intensity of specialist-led care in emergency medical admissions, focusing particularly on the organisation and delivery of care, and medical staffing. 30,31 In the case of urgent stroke care, recent studies have shown that temporal variation in mortality is now decreasing, 32,33 including in London's hyperacute stroke unit (HASU) model. 34 However, there has been no large-scale, organisational research to understand what creates temporal in consistency, particularly in services that aim to operate consistently over 7 days, such as the London stroke services.…”