Quality assurance of the university medical education, hospital services and traditional pharmaceutical products of the Bhutanese So-wa-rig-pa health care system

Abstract

BackgroundThe Bhutanese So-wa-rig-pa medicine (BSM) was integrated with the allopathic (modern) health care system in 1967. Ever since the health care integration policy was implemented, the BSM has gone through many phases of quality improvement and changes including the establishment of one university-based institute, 58 hospitals and Basic Health Units (BHU)-based health care services, and one traditional medicine factory. The BSM provides primary health care services to more than 20–30 % of patients who visit hospitals and BHU on a daily basis. However, there has been no study covering the quality assurance system of BSM. Our paper addresses this information gap.MethodsThis study was an observational ethnographic study supported by phenomenological understanding and content analysis of the data. The information was triangulated through consultation with the BSM practitioners (discussion (N = 8)) and personalized in-depth question-answer sessions using electronic protocols (N = 5). These participants comprised BSM educationists, clinical physicians, researchers, production and the quality assurance staff who were selected using convenience and purposive sampling method. The relevant So-wa-rig-pa information and literature were obtained from the government policy documents, official websites, scientific papers and the traditional medical texts. This study is enhanced by our practical observations and first-hand experience with BSM while working as the researchers at the Ministry of Health in Bhutan. In addition, the information in this paper is crosschecked and authenticated by five So-wa-rig-pa practitioners of Bhutan.ResultsThe study highlights the following: a) The BSM receives both the government and people’s support, b) The quality assurance system have been developed by integrating the traditional empirical knowledge and modern scientific protocols, c) There exist three administrative and functional organizations responsible for providing the quality BSM health care services in Bhutan, d) Extensive standard treatment guidelines and Quality documentation system exist for BSM as required by the regulatory bodies in Bhutan. The paper also recommends appropriate future directions for BSM.ConclusionsThe BSM plays significant role in the primary health care system of the country. Consequently, the quality, safety and efficacy of BSM has been given priority by the Bhutan government. Many scientific protocols were integrated with the traditional quality approaches and further scientific studies are still required to improve its quality.

Desert Endemic Plants in Algeria: A Review on Traditional Uses, Phytochemistry, Polyphenolic Compounds and Pharmacological Activities

“…There is still a dearth of literature resulting from the last decade’s investigations addressing procedures to be adopted for quality assurance, authentication, and standardization of crude plant products, despite ongoing thorough and mechanism-oriented evaluations of medicinal plants from the Saharan region’s flora. The formulation of the finished product, extraction techniques, and proper raw material management may all contribute to achieving the desired consistency [ 16 , 102 ]. In fact, it has been acknowledged that one of the main obstacles to the formation of a modern phytomedicine business in the Saharan region is the lack of proper validation of traditional knowledge, as well as technological needs and quality control standards.…”

Knowledge, Attitude, and Practice of Infection Control and Waste Management among Traditional Medicine Practitioners in Bhutan, 2019: A Nationwide Cross-Sectional Survey

“…5 Missing � 49. 6 Missing � 33. e superscripts represent the number of missing data for each variable.…”

“…e Traditional Medicine Units (TMUs) are colocated with allopathic hospitals and offer their age-old treatment recipes and healing procedures [4,5]. BTM drug recipe not only follows its traditional methods of identification, collection, and manufacturing of herbal plants but also follows modern methods of quality assurance in drug manufacturing, storage, and distribution [6]. Surgical therapies include bloodletting, oil and heat moxibustion, cupping, and the indigenous gold needle therapy that generate sharps and infectious wastes.…”

Water-Based Therapies of Bhutan: Current Practices and the Recorded Clinical Evidence of Balneotherapy

“…Herbal bath therapy is an integral part of traditional BSM health care services. We have previously described how QSE of BSM is managed and regulated under the settings of university medical education, hospital services, and pharmaceutical production processes [78]. We found that NTMH developed numerous standard guidelines and reference materials through a series of consultative workshops to provide BSM treatments with the same quality, safety, and effectiveness.…”

“…We found that NTMH developed numerous standard guidelines and reference materials through a series of consultative workshops to provide BSM treatments with the same quality, safety, and effectiveness. These guidelines are (i) diseases codes and classification system for correctly diagnosing the diseases; (ii) standard treatment guidelines for traditional medicine; (iii) national traditional medicine professional service standards; (iv) therapy guidelines (including herbal bath therapy) for traditional medicine practitioners; (v) standard operating procedures for traditional medicine services; and (vi) guidelines for detecting, reporting, and managing adverse drug reactions [78][79][80][81]. The traditional physicians and clinical assistants are trained on following, operating, and using these guidelines while providing the traditional medical health care services.…”