Quality end-of-life care for dementia: What have family carers told us so far? A narrative synthesis

Abstract

Background:People with dementia do not always receive good quality end-of-life care, with undertreated pain, aggressive medical interventions and limited access to hospice care being common. Family carers often provide the majority of informal care for people with dementia, therefore may be best placed to comment on quality of care.Aim:We explored what quality end-of-life care for dementia is from the perspective of family carers.Design:A review of qualitative evidence taking a systematic approach using a narrative synthesis with tabulation, textual description of studies and thematic analysis as tools, following the guidelines from the Economic and Social Research Council.Data sources:Keywords and subject headings were searched in MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, SCIE and PsycINFO for studies from 1990 in April 2012 and updated in May 2013. Reference lists were checked and citation searches undertaken.Results:Eight studies were included. There was an overarching theme of ‘A family’s belief of death and their choice of treatment’. Three further themes were then identified to explain family carers’ beliefs: the relationship with professionals as a core component of care quality; emotional and commitment pressures of caring and finally, family carers’ ability to think about death and dying.Conclusion:It is difficult to define what constitutes high-quality end-of-life care for people with dementia from the perspective of family carers. Their views expressed in the literature appear to demonstrate more variation of preference of care and treatment and their uncertainty of this.

The experiences and preparedness of family carers for best interest decision‐making of a relative living with advanced dementia: A qualitative study

“…In this role the “best interests” principle of the Mental Capacity Act (Department for Constitutional Affairs, ) highlights that a decision made must be done in the relative's best interest, recognizing all aspects of financial and personal welfare, but also healthcare decisions and actions. Following their narrative analysis of families’ perspectives of dementia end‐of‐life care, Davies, Maio, Rait, and Iliffe () highlighted that there remains limited research on carers’ experiences at this stage. They recommended that more information is needed from carers to provide a greater in‐depth understanding.…”

Pain in Hospice Patients With Dementia

“…Studies comparing patients with dementia and patients with cancer have found that patients with dementia were prescribed lower doses of opioids than patients with cancer with similar pain scores, and opioids were more likely to be prescribed as monotherapy in patients with dementia, which is inconsistent with industry recommendations. 9,12 …”

Health professionals generally have more restrictive attitudes towards assisted dying in dementia than the public

“…As demonstrated in this study, not all will have such a supportive view and opinions will vary. As shown in previous reviews of attitudes towards end-of-life care in dementia, carers’ views in particular may change and span a spectrum of beliefs 4. Caution would also need to be taken of any other comorbid psychological disorders such as depression, which may compound an individual's desire for assisted dying 5…”