Quality improvement priorities for safer out-of-hours palliative care: Lessons from a mixed-methods analysis of a national incident-reporting database

Abstract

Background: Patients receiving palliative care are often at increased risk of unsafe care with the out-of-hours setting presenting particular challenges. The identification of improved ways of delivering palliative care outside working hours is a priority area for policymakers. Aim: To explore the nature and causes of unsafe care delivered to patients receiving palliative care from primary-care services outside normal working hours. Design: A mixed-methods cross-sectional analysis of patient safety incident reports from the National Reporting and Learning System. We characterised reports, identified by keyword searches, using codes to describe what happened, underlying causes, harm outcome, and severity. Exploratory descriptive and thematic analyses identified factors underpinning unsafe care. Setting/participants: A total of 1072 patient safety incident reports involving patients receiving sub-optimal palliative care via the out-of-hours primary-care services. Results: Incidents included issues with: medications (n = 613); access to timely care (n = 123); information transfer (n = 102), and/or non-medication-related treatment such as pressure ulcer relief or catheter care (n = 102). Almost two-thirds of reports (n = 695) described harm with outcomes such as increased pain, emotional, and psychological distress featuring highly. Commonly identified contributory factors to these incidents were a failure to follow protocol (n = 282), lack of skills/confidence of staff (n = 156), and patients requiring medication delivered via a syringe driver (n = 80). Conclusion: Healthcare systems with primary-care-led models of delivery must examine their practices to determine the prevalence of such safety issues (communication between providers; knowledge of commonly used, and access to, medications and equipment) and utilise improvement methods to achieve improvements in care.

GPs’ decisions about prescribing end-of-life anticipatory medications: a qualitative study

“…11,12,18 A 2019 analysis of patient safety incident reports found a recurring lack of knowledge or skills in using anticipatory medications among outof-hours nursing and medical staff. 35 The current study is the first to identify that anticipatory medications are used as a sign to alert other visiting clinicians to the terminal nature of the patient's condition. Having the drugs in place enabled doctors unfamiliar with the patient to make care decisions without visiting.…”

The palliative care needs and experiences of people with advanced head and neck cancer: A scoping review

“…More widely, 'treatment related incidents' such as those relating to other interventions, for example, urinary catheters or nasogastric tubes, are a recognised factor prompting patient safety incidents during 'out-of-hours' care. 72 Additionally, obtaining timely access to care can be a challenge. 72 Solely relying on engagement with palliative care services is not sufficient to alleviate these issues.…”

The Impact of Population Ageing on End-of-Life Care in Scotland: Population-based Projections of Place of Death and Recommendations for Future Service Provision

“…This would need to be supported by appropriate tools to aid assessment and management, such as the Integrated Palliative Care Outcome Scale for Dementia (IPOS-Dem) [31,32] and decision support [33]. Palliative care delivered in the community out-ofhours poses challenges to patient safety as most resources go into in-hours care [34]. Confidence in assessing care emergencies out-of-hours is lacking; education using flexible approaches such as e-learning are required to support GPs to deliver good emergency care at the end-of-life [35].…”