Quantitative and Qualitative Analysis on Sex and Gender in Preparatory Material for National Medical Examination in Germany and the United States

Abstract

Background: Sex- and gender-based medicine (SGBM) should be a mandatory part of medical education. We compared the quantity and quality of sex- and gender-related content of e-learning materials commonly used by German and American medical students while preparing for national medical examinations. Methods: Quantitative, line-by-line analysis of the preparatory materials AMBOSS 2017 and USMLE Step 1 Lecture Notes (2017) by KAPLAN MEDICAL was performed between April and October 2017. Subjects were allocated to one of the three main fields: clinical subjects, behavioral and social science, and pharmacology. Qualitative analysis comprised binary categorization into sex- and gender-based aspects and qualification with respect to the presence of a pathophysiological explanation for the sex or gender difference. Results: In relation to the total content of AMBOSS and KAPLAN, the sex- and gender-based share of the clinical subjects content was 26.8% (±8.2) in AMBOSS and 21.1% (±10.2) in KAPLAN. The number of sex- and gender-based aspects in the behavioral and social science learning material differed significantly for AMBOSS and KAPLAN (4.4% ± 3.1% vs 10.7% ± 7.5%; P = .044). Most of the sex- and gender-related content covered sex differences. Most learning cards and texts did not include a detailed pathophysiological explanation for sex- or gender-based aspects. The knowledge provided in the preparatory documents represents only a small part of facts that are already known about sex and gender differences. Conclusions: The preparatory materials focused almost exclusively on biological sex differences and the sociocultural dimension in particular is underrepresented. A lot more evidence-based facts are known and should be integrated into the materials to reflect the importance of SGBM as an integral component of patient-centered medicine.

Virologists' Sex- and Gender-Based Medical Knowledge of COVID-19 Affects Quality of Students' Education

“… 15 , 16 Despite this disregard among health care professionals, 17–19 a growing number of physicians, lecturers, and medical students call for a revision of medical curricula. 20–22 Until sex- and gender-based teaching and assessment frameworks are implemented, 23 blended-learning didactic concepts, face-to-face interactions with online teaching methods will assist current and future medical professionals to educate themselves on sex and gender issues. 24 …”

Design, Implementation, and Evaluation of an Intensive Course on Issues in Women's Health and Gender-Based Medicine

“…4 Failure to recognize SGBM as an integral part of medical education is also reflected in the scarcity of SGBM topics covered in learning materials commonly used by German and American medical students to prepare for standardized national medical exams. 5 Currently, there is no consensus on how to best incorporate information generated from the growing field of SGBM into educational and training programs. 6,7 Recent efforts to advance sex-and gender-based health education have focused on the creation of teaching materials and tools geared toward integrating these concepts into undergraduate and postgraduate medical curricula.…”

Are stereotypes in decline? The portrayal of female anatomy in e‐learning

“…It is all the more surprising that there has been no explicit research of a possible gender bias in anatomical illustrations in Germany, which stands in contrast to the English‐speaking community. The popularity and institutionalization of sex and gender sensitive medicine, however, is gradually improving the gender awareness among the medical community in Germany (Regitz‐Zagrosek, 2012; Kulisch et al, 2020; Schluchter et al, 2020). According to a recent survey, over 90% of the medical students interviewed stated that the topic of sex and gender sensitive medicine will play a significant role in their later professional activities as physicians (Seeland et al, 2021).…”