“…As described earlier, this mechanism will not have a preference for the terminal positions. 18,19 Most importantly, a retro-aldol mechanism fails to explain why starting from xylose, threitol is the first product to appear ( Table 2, entries 11 and 12) and starting from arabinose, erythritol is the initial product ( Table 2, entries 18 and 19). The intermediate tetrulose products have a carbonyl group at the C2 position, which after hydrogenation should give both erythritol and threitol independent of the starting aldose (see RA mechanism in Scheme 2).…”