“…They considered their results as consistent with those of Balibar [14,19] at least in the sense that their observation of roton emission by atom absorption confirms the existence of the reverse process. However, in their calculations of condensation probabilities, Echenique and Pendry [26], Edwards and Fatouros [27], Goodman and Garcia [28], Usagawa [29], Swanson and Edwards [30], and Campbell [31] included the generation of ripplons, which means that, according to them, condensation and evaporation are not purely elastic one-to-one processes.…”