Meningiomas comprise approximately 20% of adult primary intracranial neoplasms.1 Of these, benign meningiomas are known to have an indolent growth pattern, usually without infiltration into adjacent nervous tissue. [2][3][4][5] Because meningiomas have a well-circumscribed character, surgery has historically been the preferred treatment when total resection can be achieved with reasonable morbidity. Surgical resection has resulted in five-, 10-, and 15-year progression-free rates of 93, 80, and 68%, respectively. 6 Despite the development of multiple techniques designed to minimize morbidity while obtaining a surgical cure, however, complete resection remains difficult and is not achievable in approximately 20-30% of presenting patients because of multiple regional involvement, severe adherence to or invasion of the brainstem, involvement of cranial nerves, or encasement of the vertebrobasilar circulation. 6-11 Currently, controversy exists as to whether skull base meningiomas, especially those involving the petroclivus and/or cavernous sinus, are best treated with radical resection, subtotal resection followed by radiosurgical treatment of the residual lesion, or radiosurgical treatment alone.
Petroclival Tumors and Cavernous ExtensionMeningiomas of the petroclival region usually involve the petrous apex and the upper two-thirds of the clivus. Appropriately, cautious subtotal resection has become the preferred treatment to reduce post-operative morbidity, along with the addition of radiation treatment of tumor remnants.
18-21Meningiomas along the medial sphenoid wing that invade the cavernous sinus are also a treatment challenge because of the possibility of tumor infiltration of the traversing cranial nerves and internal carotid artery and, to a lesser degree, the involvement of the adjacent pituitary gland. 22 The goal of surgical cure must therefore take into account local invasion of neurovascular structures within the cavernous sinus. As a consequence, several authors have emphasized the use of subtotal resection to limit the risk for permanent post-operative cranial nerve or the potential for vascular injury over complete resection. 7,9,12,23 The long-term outcome after subtotal resection of meningiomas within the cavernous sinus alone is, however, associated with an unacceptably high symptomatic recurrence rate.
24
Radiosurgical TreatmentDespite the high symptomatic recurrence rate and microsurgical improvements over the past few years, subtotal resection of meningiomas along the skull base, particularly those within the petroclival and cavernous sinus locations, remains a desired surgical outcome because such limited resection lends an acceptable level of morbidity. 7,11,[25][26][27] Because of the unacceptable morbidity of radical resection, along with the high incidence of recurrence, adjuvant techniques for treating these tumors have been developed.Early studies from the 1980s demonstrated that external-beam field radiation therapy could provide durable local tumor control for those benign meningio...