O f 111 primary ankle ligament arthroplasties (modified Evans procedure) performed between 1983 and 1994, we were able to identify 89 patients (94 ankles) for follow-up. All were under 50 years of age. Two had died and one refused to co-operate; 86 patients (91 ankles) were therefore reviewed, 25 by telephone and the remainder by clinical examination with all but three also undergoing radiological review.Of the 91 ankles, 70 had no or very mild pain and 72 had no or rare episodes of instability and when considered together only 59 (65%) had no or mild pain and minimal instability. Injuries of the lateral ligament complex of the ankle are common.1 Opinions on the treatment of an acute disruption of the lateral ligament complex have varied between early repair and non-operative management. The latter is the mainstay of treatment with emphasis on early mobilisation rather than immobilisation in a cast.
1-3A large number of methods of reconstruction have been described, many being slight variations of the same technique. The techniques are either non-anatomical with a tendon graft or fascia lata, 4-8 or anatomical in which the remnants of the ligaments are either repaired or sutured to bone, with or without augmentation with another structure such as the inferior extensor retinaculum.
9Anatomical reconstructions have been shown to reduce talar tilt and the anterior-drawer sign to a greater extent than occurs with non-anatomical reconstructions.7-9 While the short-term results are good, the long-term results are unknown.The short-and long-term results for various non-anatomical reconstructions have, however, been well documented and vary considerably. [10][11][12][13] The Evans procedure is a nonanatomical reconstruction which was first described in 1953 4 as a dynamic stabilisation of the ankle. The tendon of peroneus brevis is divided below the musculotendinous junction and passed through a tunnel drilled in the fibula, starting distally at the tip of the fibula and emerging posteriorly and superiorly. The tendon is then re-attached to its muscle belly. Since the initial description the procedure has been modified by two main variations. One involves routing the tendon of peroneus brevis posterosuperiorly through the tunnel so that it emerges at the tip of the fibula, and then attaching it alongside its insertion at the base of the fifth metatarsal. 11,12 The second variation follows the original procedure, but all or part of the tendon is taken through the tunnel and sutured to the fibular periosteum, thus allowing it to act as a tenodesis rather than a dynamic stabiliser. The senior authors (PJD, KRA, PLL, TMS) have used the second modification of the Evans procedure since 1983. We have studied retrospectively all such patients to determine long-term satisfaction, stability, hindfoot biomechanics and the rate of degenerative changes.