Radius ratio dependency of the instability of fully compressible convection in rapidly rotating spherical shells

Abstract

Based on the fully compressible Navier–Stokes equations, the linear stability of thermal convection in rapidly rotating spherical shells of various radius ratios $\eta$ is studied for a wide range of Taylor number $Ta$ , Prandtl number $Pr$ and the number of density scale height $N_\rho$ . Besides the classical inertial mode and columnar mode, which are widely studied by the Boussinesq approximation and anelastic approximation, the quasi-geostrophic compressible mode is also identified in a wide range of $N_\rho$ and $Pr$ for all $\eta$ considered, and this mode mainly occurs in the convection with relatively small $Pr$ and large $N_\rho$ . The instability processes are classified into five categories. In general, for the specified wavenumber $m$ , the parameter space ( $Pr, N_\rho$ ) of the fifth category, in which the base state loses stability via the quasi-geostrophic compressible mode and remains unstable, shrinks as $\eta$ increases. The asymptotic scaling behaviours of the critical Rayleigh numbers $Ra_c$ and corresponding wavenumbers $m_c$ to $Ta$ are found at different $\eta$ for the same instability mode. As $\eta$ increases, the flow stability is strengthened. Furthermore, the linearized perturbation equations and Reynolds–Orr equation are employed to quantitatively analyse the mechanical mechanisms and flow instability mechanisms of different modes. In the quasi-geostrophic compressible mode, the time-derivative term of disturbance density in the continuity equation and the diffusion term of disturbance temperature in the energy equation are found to be critical, while in the columnar and inertial modes, they can generally be ignored. Because the time-derivative term of the disturbance density in the continuity equation cannot be ignored, the anelastic approximation fails to capture the instability mode in the small- $Pr$ and large- $N_\rho$ system, where convection onset is dominated by the quasi-geostrophic compressible mode. However, all the modes are primarily governed by the balance between the Coriolis force and the pressure gradient, based on the momentum equation. Physically, the most important difference between the quasi-geostrophic compressible mode and the columnar mode is the role played by the disturbance pressure. The disturbance pressure performs negative work for the former mode, which appears to stabilize the flow, while it destabilizes the flow for the latter mode. As $\eta$ increases, in the former mode the relative work performed by the disturbance pressure increases and in the latter mode decreases.

Three-dimensional quasiperiodic torsional flows in rotating spherical fluids at very low Prandtl numbers

“…Very small time steps must be taken due to the small period of the oscillations, and the proximity of various branches of solutions lengthen the transients. Despite the difficulties, the experimental and numerical studies have intensified in recent years, reaching low Ekman numbers at the very low Pr of liquid metals, E, [1][2][3][4], or taking into account new phenomena such us the precession of the rotating spheres [5], the compressibility of the fluid [6,7], the influence of Robin [8] and fixed-flux [9] boundary conditions for the temperature, or attaining the fully developed turbulence [10,11].…”