We present a spectroscopic study of Mn-doped Mg 2 TiO 4 as a function of pressure and temperature to check its viability as a red-emitting phosphor. The synthesis following a solid-state reaction route yields not only the formation of Mn 4+ but also small traces of Mn 3+ . Although we show that Mn 4+ photoluminescence is not appreciably affected by the presence of Mn 3+ , its local structure at the substituted Ti 4+ host site causes a reduction of the Mn 4+ pumping efficiency yielding a drastic quantum-yield reduction at room temperature. By combining Raman and time-resolved emission and excitation spectroscopies, we propose a model for explaining the puzzling nonradiative and inefficient pumping processes attained in this material. In addition, we unveil a structural phase transition above 14 GPa that worsens their photoluminescence capabilities. The decrease of emission intensity and lifetime with increasing temperature following different thermally activated de-excitation pathways is mostly related to relatively small activation energies and the electric−dipole transition mechanism associated with coupling to odd-parity vibrational modes. A thorough model based on the configurational energy level diagram to the A 1g normal mode fairly accounts for the observed excitation and emissionthe quantum yieldof this material.