Objectives
To compare 3 different treatment regimens for vitamin D deficiency in minority adolescents and to explore factors that impact treatment efficacy.
Study design
We conducted an 8-week, prospective, open-label, randomized clinical trial in an urban, academic, children’s hospital. 183 vitamin D-deficient adolescents [mean 25(OH)D 13.7±3.9 ng/mL; mean age 16.6±2.2 years] were randomized into 3 vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) treatment arms: 50,000IU/week; 5,000IU/day; and 1,000IU/day. Serum 25(OH)D and vitamin D binding protein (VDBP) levels were measured pre-and post-treatment.122 (67%) participants completed post-treatment measures. Complete-case and multiple-imputation, intention-to-treat analyses were performed.
Results
Mean change in 25(OH)D level post-treatment was significantly different among the 3 arms, 24.9±15.1vs. 21.0±15.2 vs. 6.2±6.5 ng/mL, for 50,000IU, 5,000IU, and 1,000IU doses, respectively, p<0.001. Both high-dose treatments were effective in increasing the 25(OH)D level out of deficiency range (≥20ng/mL) in more than 80% of participants, and 60% remained deficient after low-dose treatment. Only 72%, 56%, and 2% achieved vitamin D sufficiency (>30ng/mL) with 50,000IU, 5,000IU, and 1,000IU doses, respectively, p<0.001. Obese participants had substantially less mean change in 25(OH)D level after treatment than normal-weight participants, 13.7±10.7 vs. 21.9±16.9 ng/mL, p<0.001. Mean baseline VDBP level was almost twice as high in Hispanic compared with black participants (p<0.001) and did not alter treatment response or change with treatment.
Conclusions
Adult-sized adolescents require 8-weeks of high-dose cholecalciferol, at least 5,000IU/day, to correct deficiency. Obese adolescents have poorer response to treatment and may need higher doses than non-obese youth. Hispanic and black adolescents have different VDBP levels but similar treatment responses.