Rational or demoralized responses to work restructuring in Hong Kong?

Abstract

A B S T R AC TOwing to the paucity of data demonstrating workers' reactions to work restructuring, the study examines possible reactions in terms of job performance, attendance at training, and voicing of discontent. It predicts the effects of work restructuring and background characteristics with reference to the exit-voice-loyalty model and demoralization theory. A telephone survey of a random sample of households collected data from 1176 workers in Hong Kong. Supportive of the demoralization theory, work restructuring over the previous past year appeared to reduce workers' intended job performance, attendance at training, and voicing of discontent. These findings hold for workers with various characteristics and restructuring in work outcomes, work processes, and staffing. Demoralization theory offers a reasonable explanation of the findings regarding the negative effects of work restructuring. In addition, income and social class have profound influences on workers' reactions. K E Y WO R D Sdemoralization job training loyalty-exit-voice model organizational loyalty voicing discontent work restructuring Despite the prevalence of work restructuring in Hong Kong, as well as in other developed societies, research evidence about the impacts of restructuring on workers is lacking. To tackle this knowledge gap, the present study examines Hong Kong workers' intended work performance, attendance at 2 2 3 Human Relations

Hong Kong Children's Posited “Vulnerability” to Social Influence on Substance Abuse

“…This finding is contrary to the expectation of strain theory. The negative effect of strain tends to reflect the demoralizing effect of strain, which is consistent with previous research (Cheung, 2005;Ngai and Cheung, 2005). Accordingly, strain generally discourages the person from engaging in activities, including delinquency and substance use.…”

Chinese Migrants' Class Mobility in Hong Kong

“…According to structural fit theory, these resources may not fit the Hong Kong way of life. For instance, work experience before migration may not be relevant to work in Hong Kong, probably because of discrepancies in the work system between Hong Kong and the mainland, such as the levels of post‐industrialisation, job security, and the requirements for worker competitiveness and quality performance (Cheung, ; Chiu and Lui, ). Accordingly, work on the mainland is less competitive and less skilled, while workers receive more benefits and protection from their work organisations (Lin and Lai, ; Xiang and Li, ).…”

Impact of Internet Channel on the Service Cannibalization Perception and the Role of Relative Capital

“…More specifically, the concept of job alienation is a psychological change that results in an imbalance between the effort made and the results achieved. Innovative changes in the tourism distribution system have led to changes in the development of the operator, new skills and changes inherent in the nature of the business and put more pressure on the employees (Di Pietro and Pizam, 2008), and in addition, they reveal the feeling of alienation (Cheung, 2005). In the work of Sharma and Gassenheimer (2009) and in other studies, it has been found that cannibalization expected by the sales representatives of the presence of the internet option increases the uncertainty in the workplace (Berger, 1979(Berger, , 1986Planalp and Honeycutt, 1985;Shannon and Weaver, 1949).…”