(Re)Conceptualizing the Political Economy of the African State Form: The Strong/Weak State Contradiction in Angola

Abstract

This article is a theoretical contribution to the debate on African statehood. We use the Angolan state as a 'sounding board' for a mainstream neo-Weberian perspective and an oppositional historicist approach. We argue that the neo-Weberians inadequately explain the genealogy of state power and the historicists fail to provide a functionalist account of the state's relation to society. Neo-Weberians capture some of the basic facts related to a 'successful failed Angolan state' and historicists focus on governance legitimation strategies. As a way forward, we propose an eclectic theoretical alternative which draws on the work of Mahmood Mamdani and Robert W. Cox. We argue that their approaches provide us with the outlines of an explanation of statesociety relations in Africa which is contextualized in both space and time. This explanation, which regards history as a process, focuses on and encourages us to identify an African ideal-type of the state, which is different from the Eurocentric neo-Weberian ideal-type.

China and Latecomer Industrialization Processes in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Case of Combined and Uneven Development

“…Hegemony is maintained not only through coercion and exclusion but also through building consent through both material and non-material means. The end of the civil war (and the elimination of UNITA [União Nacional para a Independência Total de Angola] military resistance to MPLA hegemony) might have led the MPLA elite to shift strategies from the use of coercion (in this case, armed conflict) to building consent through the civil society and otherwise (Solli and Leysens 2011).…”

An anatomy of colonial states and fiscal regimes in Portuguese Africa: long-term transformations in Angola and Mozambique, 1850s-1970s

“…My conceptualisation of the metropolitan and the colonial African states has been influenced by the work of Solli and Leysens (2011) on "the strong/weak state contradiction" in post-colonial Angola, where state strength and weakness are approached from both a neo-…”