Identifying individual reactive intermediates within the “zoo”
of organometallic species that form on catalytic surfaces during reactions
is a long-standing challenge in heterogeneous catalysis. Here, we
identify distinct reactive intermediates, all of which exist at low
coverages, that lead to distinguishable reaction pathways during the
hydrogenolysis of 2-methyltetrahydrofuran (MTHF) on Ni,
Ni12P5, and Ni2P catalysts by combining
advanced spectroscopic methods with quantum chemical calculations.
Each of these reactive complexes cleaves specific C–O bonds,
gives rise to unique products, and exhibits different apparent activation
barriers for ring opening. The spectral features of the reactive intermediates
are extracted by collecting in situ infrared spectra while sinusoidally
modulating the H2 pressure during MTHF hydrogenolysis and
applying phase-sensitive detection (PSD), which suppresses the features
of inactive surface species. The combined spectra of all reactive
species are deconvoluted using singular-value decomposition techniques
that yield spectra and changes in surface coverage for each set of
kinetically differentiable species. These deconvoluted spectra are
consistent with predicted spectral features for the reactive surface
intermediates implicated by detailed kinetic measurements and DFT
calculations. Notably, these methods give direct evidence for several
anticipated differences in the coordination and composition of reactive
MTHF-derived species. The compositions of the most abundant reactive
intermediate (MARI) on Ni, Ni12P5, and Ni2P nanoparticles during the C–O bond rupture of MTHF
are identical; however, MARI changes orientation from Ni3(μ3-C5H10O) to Ni3(η5-C5H10O) (i.e., lies more
parallel with the catalyst surface) with increasing phosphorus content.
The shift in binding configuration with phosphorus content suggests
that the decrease in steric hindrance to rupture the 3C–O
bond is the fundamental cause of increased selectivity toward 3C–O bond rupture. Previous kinetic measurements and
DFT calculations indicate that C–O bond rupture occurs on Ni
ensembles on Ni, Ni12P5, and Ni2P
catalysts; however, the addition of more electronegative phosphorus
atoms that withdraw a small charge from Ni ensembles results in differences
in the binding configuration, activation enthalpy, and selectivity.
The results from this in situ spectroscopic methodology support previous
proposals that the manipulation of the electronic structure of metal
ensembles by the introduction of phosphorus provides strategies for
designing catalysts for the selective cleavage of hindered C–X
bonds and demonstrate the utility of this approach in identifying
individual reactive species within the zoo.