We present a comprehensive overview of our current
knowledge of the interactions of valence
M(nsnp 3P)
and M(nsnp 1P1) excited
states with H−H, Si−H, and C−H bonds, where M = Mg, Zn, Cd, and
Hg. It is
proposed that the high reactivity of
M(nsnp 3P1) states with
H−H and Si−H bonds compared to C−H bonds
is due to the lack of steric hindrance in the localized, side-on,
M(npπ)−XH(σ*) donor−acceptor
molecular
orbital interactions, since the Si−H bond length in SiH4
is ∼1.5 Å compared to C−H bond lengths of ∼1.1
Å. It is also concluded that
Mg(3s3p 1P1) and
Zn(4s4p 1P1) efficiently activate C−H
bonds as well as H−H
and Si−H bonds not just because of their higher energy but because of
better M(npπ)−XH(σ*) energy matches
and overlap, which overcomes M(ns)−XH(σ) repulsion
and the steric hindrance. It is further proposed that
the striking differences in the microscopic mechanisms of attack of
C−H bonds by Mg(1P1) versus
Zn(1P1)
may be due to the fact that the Zn(4s) “core” is substantially
(∼0.2 Å) smaller than the Mg(3s) “core”,
allowing true insertion of the Zn(1P1)
state (but not the Mg(1P1) state) into
C−H bonds to form (by surface
hopping) long-lived ground-state zinc alkyl hydrides which decompose in
a non-RRKM fashion to yield the
observed ZnH product. Finally, the experimental results to date
(as well as ab initio calculations) indicate
that direct, end-on “abstractive” attack of
M(nsnp 1P1) states [as
well as O(1D2)] of H−H, Si−H, and
C−H
bonds probably does not occur.