Real unit labour costs in Eurozone countries: drivers and clusters

Abstract

We examine the trajectories of the real unit labour costs (RULCs) in a selection of Eurozone economies. Strong asymmetries in the convergence process of the RULCs and its components-real wages, capital intensity, and technology-are uncovered through decomposition and cluster analyses. In the last three decades, the PIIGS (Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece, and Spain) succeeded in reducing their RULCs by more than their northern partners. With the exception of Ireland, however, technological progress was weak; it was through capital intensification that periphery economies gained efficiency and competitiveness. Cluster heterogeneity, and lack of robustness in cluster composition, is a reflection of the difficulties in achieving real convergence and, by extension, nominal convergence. We conclude by outlining technology as the key convergence factor, and call for a wider strategy in labour market policies, which should be more oriented to promote the sources of productivity growth. JEL Classification numbers: F43; F62; O47; O52

Social Exclusion and Convergence in the EU: An Assessment of the Europe 2020 Strategy

“…There is abundant literature on testing for convergence in the EU, both at national [3,5,6] and at regional level [16][17][18][19]. Unsurprisingly, most of the literature rejects overall convergence in favour of cluster convergence.…”

“…). Rather, it has boosted some structural divergencies that were already present in the growth model of these economies' [5]. Similarly, Díaz del Hoyo et al [2] also find that total factor productivity is the key driver of convergence and that the differences in productivity between southern European countries and the higher-income countries existed long before the introduction of the euro.…”

“…Evidence of club convergence may indicate divergence in a group of countries and cast doubt on the sustainability of the integrated area. Ordóñez et al [5] conclude that, after years of ever-closer economic integration, EMU countries have also converged to different steady states in competitiveness, measured as real unit labour costs, and in capital accumulation and total factor productivity. According to these authors, the fact that EMU countries have converged to different long-run equilibrium levels in terms of the growth drivers (capital accumulation and total factor productivity) points to the fact that the imbalances at the root of the euro crisis are related to the specificities of the growth model in the periphery and core European countries.…”

The education pillar of the Europe 2020 strategy: a convergence analysis

“…This club convergence is a possible form of conditional convergence, where economies belonging to a group of countries share similar features. Similarly, Ordóñez et al (2015) also find club convergence in competitiveness measured as real unit labour costs, and in capital accumulation and total factor productivity. According to Monfort et al (2018), the lack of real economic convergence can also be observed in income inequality and unemployment.…”

Unit labour costs and the dynamics of output and unemployment in the southern European crisis countries

“…One consists of papers that find competitiveness to have affected growth. Ordóñez et al (2015) conclude that the economic crisis was caused by differences in competitiveness which generated real divergences and growing current account imbalances. Consistent with this view, Caporale and Gil-Alana (2014) find evidence that misalignment of the real exchange rate affects longer-term growth.…”