“…Experiences across the world (Burgin, 2010;Gordon et al, 2015;Kaiser, 2001;Kihslinger, 2008;Maron et al, 2015Maron et al, , 2012Robertson, 2004Robertson, , 2012Santos et al, 2015;Brock, 2015, among others) have shown that the ecological 'success rate' of offsetting was questionable at best. They point to the problems of measurements, accounting methods and lack of fungibility and commensurability of nature (Maron et al, 2015;Niner et al, 2017;Pawliczek and Sullivan, 2011;Robertson, 2004Robertson, , 2012Sullivan and Hannis, 2015). Scholars have illustrated the value struggles and the politics around offsetting tools and measurements (Robertson, 2012;Sullivan and Hannis, 2015), and offered compelling critiques of the economic rationality and quantitative frameworks underlying the offsetting ideology and the profit accumulation through offsetting (e.g.…”