“…The calculated content of elements in different valence states should be treated critically, as the analysis method can introduce a systemic error. Specifically, the higher contents of Cu 3+ , Cu + , and Ti 3+ ions on the ceramic surface, as determined by XPS under visible light and high vacuum [ 3 , 46 ], can be attributed to the oxidation/reduction of ions under measurement conditions. However, this data is useful for comparative assessment of the chemical state of elements on the surface of samples.…”