For cell and gene therapies to become more broadly accessible, it is critical to develop and optimize non-viral cell type-preferential gene carriers such as lipid nanoparticles (LNPs).Despite the effectiveness of high throughput screening (HTS) approaches in expediting LNP discovery, they are often costly, labor-intensive, and often do not provide actionable LNP design rules that focus screening efforts on the most relevant chemical and formulation parameters. Here we employed a machine learning (ML) workflow using well-curated plasmid DNA LNP transfection datasets across six cell types to maximize chemical insights from HTS studies and has achieved predictions with 5–9% error on average depending on cell type. By applying Shapley additive explanations to our ML models, we unveiled composition-function relationships dictating cell type-preferential LNP transfection efficiency. Notably, we identified consistent LNP composition parameters that enhancein vitrotransfection efficiency across diverse cell types, such as ionizable to helper lipid ratios near 1:1 or 10:1 and the incorporation of cationic/zwitterionic helper lipids. In addition, several parameters were found to modulate cell type-preferentiality, including the ionizable and helper lipid total molar percentage, N/P ratio, cholesterol to PEGylated lipid ratio, and the chemical identity of the helper lipid. This study leverages HTS of compositionally diverse LNP libraries and ML analysis to understand the interactions between lipid components in LNP formulations; and offers fundamental insights that contribute to the establishment of unique sets of LNP compositions tailored for cell type-preferential transfection.