Ibbotson, M. R., N.S.C. Price, and N. A. Crowder. On the division of cortical cells into simple and complex types: a comparative viewpoint. J Neurophysiol 93: 3699 -3702, 2005. First published January 19, 2005 doi:10.1152/jn.01159.2004. Hubel and Weisel introduced the concept of cells in cat primary visual cortex being partitioned into two categories: simple and complex. Subsequent authors have developed a quantitative measure to distinguish the two cell types based on the ratio between modulated responses at the stimulus frequency (F 1 ) and unmodulated (F 0 ) components of the spiking responses to drifting sinusoidal gratings. It has been shown that cells in anesthetized cat and monkey cortex have bimodal distributions of F 1 /F 0 ratios. A clear local minimum or dip exists in the distribution at a ratio close to unity. Here we present a comparison of the distributions of the F 1 /F 0 ratios between cells in the primary visual cortex of the eutherian cat and marsupial Tammar wallaby, Macropus eugenii. This is the first quantitative description of any marsupial cortex using the F 1 /F 0 ratio and follows earlier papers showing that cells in wallaby cortex are tightly oriented and spatial frequency tuned. The results reveal a bimodal distribution in the wallaby F 1 /F 0 ratios that is very similar to that found in the rat, cat, and monkey. Discussion focuses on the mechanisms that could lead to such similar cell distributions in animals with diverse behaviors and phylogenies.
I N T R O D U C T I O NHubel and Weisel (1962) first categorized cells in the primary visual cortices of cats into two distinct cell types: simple and complex. The distinction was based on the spiking responses of cells during four visual tests. Simple cells 1) have spatially segregated ON and OFF regions within their receptive fields; 2) show summation within each subregion; 3) have antagonistic ON and OFF subregions; and 4) have responses that can be predicted based on the organization of their receptive field (RF) subregions. Cells that did not meet all or any of these criteria were classified as complex. Since the pioneering observations of Hubel and Weisel, a method was developed to quantify the simple and complex categories based on the spiking responses of the cells to moving sinusoidal gratings (De Valois et al. 1982; Movshon et al. 1978a,b; for review, Skottun et al. 1991). The method calculates the mean response of the cells above spontaneous rate during the period of motion (F 0 ) and the amplitude of oscillations at the fundamental temporal frequency of the stimulus (F 1 ). An F 1 /F 0 ratio is then calculated. Skottun et al. (1991) showed that, when the ratios were plotted for a large population of cells in cat and monkey V1, the neurons fell into a bimodal distribution with peaks at ratios of 1.7 and 0.2-0.3. There was a clear minimum or dip close to an F 1 /F 0 ratio of unity. Separating the neuron types based on those with F 1 /F 0 ratios Ͼ1 or Ͻ1 produced a distribution that correlated well with the classifications based ...