“…This model, however, is limited in four respects. Firstly, its foundation rests upon a small number of modern studies (Smith, , 1989Choi et al, 2004;Dalrymple & Choi, 2007;Dalrymple et al, 2012;Johnson & Dashtgard, 2014), whilst relying heavily on observations from ancient fluvial-tidal settings (Hubbard et al, 2011;Fustic et al, 2012;Feldman & Demko, 2015;Martinius et al, 2015;Jablonski & Dalrymple, 2016), where the planform geometry, and hydraulic initial and boundary conditions, are not well-constrained. Secondly, it implies that IHS is strongly related to tidal-processes, and de-emphasizes the potential importance of fluvial and wind-wave processes (Smith et al, 2009(Smith et al, , 2011Durkin et al, 2015;Moreton & Carter, 2015) in producing IHS.…”