Reconceptualising fair access to highly academically selective universities

Abstract

The higher education regulator for England has set challenging new widening access targets requiring universities to rethink how merit is judged in admissions. Universities are being encouraged to move away from the traditional meritocratic equality of opportunity model of fair access, which holds that university places should go to the most highly qualified candidates irrespective of social background, in accordance with the principles of procedural fairness. Instead, they are being asked to move towards what we term the meritocratic equity of opportunity model, which holds that prospective students’ qualifications should be judged in light of the socioeconomic circumstances in which these were obtained to enhance distributive fairness, a practice known in the UK as contextualised admissions. In this paper, we critically discuss the theoretical underpinnings of these two competing perspectives on fair access and review the existing empirical evidence base, drawing together for the first time insights from our ESRC and Nuffield Foundation funded studies of fair access to highly academically selective universities in England. We argue that reconceptualising fair access in terms of distributive fairness rather than procedural fairness offers a more socially just set of principles on which to allocate valuable but scarce places at the most academically selective universities in England, unless or until such time as the vertical stratification of higher education institutions is reduced or eliminated entirely.

Exploring the BME Attainment Gap in a Russell Group University: A Mixed Methods Case-Study

“…Indeed, the case-study approach adopted here is intensive rather than exhaustive. That said, and whilst the results are necessarily descriptive of the sample-and the quantitative component is, perhaps, not as recent as we might wish-moderate generalizations can be made and there is reason to suspect that many of the findings would resonate and transfer across faculties and other similar universities [1,21,36]. We also recognize that issues relating to class and socio-economic circumstance are likely to feature heavily in the experiences of some BME groups.…”

“…They are widely perceived to have a research-intensive focus and are selective, attracting some of the highest achieving students in the country. However, while recent research has demonstrated that applicants from traditionally underrepresented groups are less likely to be offered places than their peers [4,5,36], there has been comparatively little exploration of how this might be translated into the experiences of BME students who do enter such institutions.…”

Does grammar school attendance increase the likelihood of attending a prestigious UK university?

“…Worryingly, these disparities persist even after controlling for attainment at Key Stages 4 and 5. It should be noted, however, that the cohort to which these findings relate came of traditional university‐going age in 2008, 10 years prior to the replacement of the Office for Fair Access by the Office for Students and the subsequent introduction of new widened access targets for England's most selective universities (Boliver et al., 2022). Given that the most selective universities have since committed to achieving these new targets and implementing a range of measures to better support socioeconomically disadvantaged students into and through university (Boliver & Powell, 2023), it is to be hoped that disparities in university entry rates are less pronounced for contemporary 18 year olds.…”

Roma University Students in Spain: Who Are They?

“…Universities tend to be conceived and designed for traditional students, who are not emancipated and for whom studying is their main activity. The rigidity of Spanish university structures hinders the university careers of other students, increasing educational inequality by favouring those who have sufficient means, generally provided by families, to be able to dedicate themselves exclusively to studies [51]. This is of special relevance for the Roma community because it is a group with significant economic needs and they rarely receive from their families the necessary economic support to dedicate their time exclusively to university.…”