Recruitment strategies for predominantly low-income, multi-racial/ethnic children and parents to 3-year community-based intervention trials: Childhood Obesity Prevention and Treatment Research (COPTR) Consortium

Abstract

Background The recruitment of participants into community-based randomized controlled trials studying childhood obesity is often challenging, especially from low-income racial/ethnical minorities and when long-term participant commitments are required. This paper describes strategies used to recruit and enroll predominately low-income racial/ethnic minority parents and children into the Childhood Obesity Prevention and Treatment Research (COPTR) consortium. Methods The COPTR consortium has run four independent 3-year, multi-level (individual, family, school, clinic, and community) community-based randomized controlled trials. Two were prevention trials in preschool children and the other two were treatment trials in pre-adolescents and adolescent youth. All trials reported monthly participant recruitment numbers using a standardized method over the projected 18–24 months of recruitment. After randomization of participants was completed, recruitment staff and investigators from each trial retrospectively completed a survey of recruitment strategies and their perceived top three recruitment strategies and barriers. Results Recruitment was completed in 15–21 months across trials, enrolling a total of 1745 parent-child dyads- out of 6314 screened. The number of children screened per randomized child was 4.6 and 3.5 in the two prevention trials, and 3.1 and 2.5 in the two treatment trials. Recruitment strategies reported included: (1) careful planning, (2) working with trusting community partners, (3) hiring recruitment staff who were culturally sensitive, personality appropriate, and willing to work flexible hours, (4) contacting potential participants actively and repeatedly, (5) recruiting at times and locations convenient for participants, (6) providing incentives to participants to complete baseline measures, (7) using a tracking database, (8) evaluating whether participants understand the activities and expectations of the study, and (9) assessing participants’ motivation for participating. Working with community partners, hiring culturally sensitive staff, and contacting potential participants repeatedly were cited by two trials among their top three strategies. The requirement of a 3-year commitment to the trial was cited by two trials to be among the top three recruitment barriers. Conclusions Comprehensive strategies that include community partnership support, culturally sensitive recruitment staff, and repeated contacts with potential participants can result in successful recruitment of low-income racial/ethnic minority families into obesity prevention and treatment trials. Trial registration NET-Works trial: ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT01606891 . Registered on 28 May 2012. GROW trial: ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT01316653 . Registered on 16 March 2011. GOALS trial: ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT016428...

Assets and Challenges to Recruiting and Engaging Families in a Childhood Obesity Treatment Research Trial: Insights From Academic Partners, Community Partners, and Study Participants

“…Communications informing the target population about the purpose and processes of the research helps foster trust and encourage participation ( 48 – 50 ). Messaging about the study during enrollment should emphasize benefits in easy to understand language and explain procedures like randomization ( 41 , 46 ). For example, community CAB members identified that intervention benefits were obscured under technical consent procedures and that predetermined intervention preferences and mistrust of randomization processes were causing dissatisfaction and potentially influencing early dropout.…”

Medical Students Pilot Nutrition and Cooking Program for Children in Underserved Communities

“…Knowing that the program attracts more children and retains more children in the 10-12 year old age range, a more focused effort regarding advertising and teaching delivery will be directed at this specific age group. 10 Although the posttest group showed an average improvement in nutrition knowledge over the pretest group, this finding may be inconsequential since posttest groups only improved by 0.6 of a question overall. Hereafter, participants will be randomly assigned numbers to track individual development from pretest surveys to posttest surveys.…”

“…This data can also bolster understanding of retention rates to determine if location, demographics, or participation in other programs from a trusted organization impacts retention. 10 The program averaged a retention rate of 50% from week one to week four. In the future, the program will explore if vacation and travel impacts participation in programs hosted over the summer.…”

Recruitment strategies for a pragmatic cluster randomized oral health trial in pediatric primary care settings

“…But, clinical trials for addressing medical conditions (e.g. coronary heart disease, obesity) have successfully recruited participants at the practice, provider, and patient levels in primary care settings [ [14] , [15] , [16] , [17] ]. The successful strategies at the practice and provider levels included academic detailing, peer recruitment, leveraging professional associations, conducting pilot studies, and engaging communities of interest [ 11 , 13 , 18 , 19 ].…”