“…This implies that a texture is required for columnar grains to form. In fact, as noted earlier, columnar grains can be produced in high-purity nickel by directional recrystallization, in the absence of particles, at the appropriate hot-zone velocities if the appropriate texture is present [35,36,[43][44][45]. In other words, particles are not necessary to produce a columnar grain structure, which is in agreement with the conclusion of Baloch and Bhadeshia [6].…”