Nitrogenase is a multicomponent metalloenzyme that catalyzes the conversion of atmospheric dinitrogen to ammonia. For decades, it has been generally believed that the [8Fe-7S] P-cluster of nitrogenase component 1 is indispensable for nitrogenase activity. In this study, we identified two catalytically active P-cluster variants by activity assays, metal analysis, and EPR spectroscopic studies. Further, we showed that both P-cluster variants resemble [4Fe-4S]-like centers based on x-ray absorption spectroscopic experiments. We believe that our findings challenge the dogma that the standard P-cluster is the only cluster species capable of supporting substrate reduction at the FeMo cofactor and provide important insights into the general mechanism of nitrogenase catalysis and assembly.MoFe protein ͉ VFe protein N itrogenase catalyzes one of the most remarkable chemical transformations in biological systems, the reduction of atmospheric dinitrogen to a bioavailable form, ammonia. Three classes of nitrogenase systems, namely, the Mo-, V-, and Fe-only nitrogenases, have been identified (for recent reviews see refs. 1-11). f Although encoded by different structural genes, all three nitrogenases are comprised of two essential component metalloproteins, component 1 (MoFe, VFe, or FeFe protein) and component 2 (Fe protein). g The homodimeric Fe protein of the Mo-nitrogenase has one [4Fe-4S] cluster bridged between the two subunits, whereas the ␣ 2  2 -tetrameric MoFe protein contains two unique metal clusters per ␣-subunit: the [8Fe-7S] P-cluster (14), which is located at the ␣-interface, and the [Mo-7Fe-9S-X-homocitrate] h FeMo cofactor (FeMoco), which is situated within the ␣-subunit. ATP-dependent electron transfer is believed to proceed from the [4Fe-4S] cluster of the Fe protein to the P-cluster of the MoFe protein and finally to FeMoco where substrate reduction takes place. The Fe protein of the V-nitrogenase shares a high degree of homology with the Fe protein of the Mo-nitrogenase and, apart from the presence of an additional ␥-subunit, the VFe protein is also believed to be highly homologous to the MoFe protein with respect not only to the structural genes encoding the ␣-and -subunits, but also to the redox centers contained within the protein, designated the P-cluster and the FeV cofactor (FeVco), respectively, in this case (4, 10, 16). The structurally homologous heterometal centers, i.e., FeMoco and FeVco, are also categorically termed cofactors.It is generally believed that the structural integrity of the P-cluster is indispensable for nitrogenase reactivity. However, the exact mechanism by which the P-cluster carries out its function in substrate reduction and, in particular, the oxidation states and structural conformations of the P-cluster involved in this process, remain largely a puzzle (17). Two types of cofactordeficient MoFe or VFe protein variants, generated by nifH or nifB deletion, i respectively, have been used to study the features of P-clusters without the interference of the cofactor centers...