cAs biofilms grow, resident cells inevitably face the challenge of resource limitation. In the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa PA14, electron acceptor availability affects matrix production and, as a result, biofilm morphogenesis. The secreted matrix polysaccharide Pel is required for pellicle formation and for colony wrinkling, two activities that promote access to O 2 . We examined the exploitability and evolvability of Pel production at the air-liquid interface (during pellicle formation) and on solid surfaces (during colony formation). Although Pel contributes to the developmental response to electron acceptor limitation in both biofilm formation regimes, we found variation in the exploitability of its production and necessity for competitive fitness between the two systems. The wild type showed a competitive advantage against a non-Pel-producing mutant in pellicles but no advantage in colonies. Adaptation to the pellicle environment selected for mutants with a competitive advantage against the wild type in pellicles but also caused a severe disadvantage in colonies, even in wrinkled colony centers. Evolution in the colony center produced divergent phenotypes, while adaptation to the colony edge produced mutants with clear competitive advantages against the wild type in this O 2 -replete niche. In general, the structurally heterogeneous colony environment promoted more diversification than the more homogeneous pellicle. These results suggest that the role of Pel in community structure formation in response to electron acceptor limitation is unique to specific biofilm models and that the facultative control of Pel production is required for PA14 to maintain optimum benefit in different types of communities.
Most bacteria form multicellular communities called biofilms by producing and encasing themselves in matrices of secreted polymers (1). The National Institutes of Health has estimated that more than half of all bacterial infections involve such biofilm formation, a feature that complicates treatment due to a variety of associated mechanisms that confer increased antibiotic resistance and tolerance in these communities (2). Steep chemical gradients that form within cellular aggregates give rise to microenvironmental heterogeneity; consequently, cells in biofilms exist in diverse physiological states, at least some of which are unique to this lifestyle. For example, in the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa PA14, some genes expressed specifically in biofilms are critical for the establishment of lung infections in a mouse model (3). A better understanding of the physiology of biofilm development is required for rational approaches to new therapies for many types of bacterial infections.Using a colony biofilm model, we have found that a primary factor influencing P. aeruginosa PA14 community morphology is the availability of electron acceptors (4-6). As colonies increase in thickness, the formation of O 2 gradients renders the community anoxic at depth and leads to an increase in intr...