Reducing COVID-19 risk in schools: a qualitative examination of secondary school staff and family views and concerns in the South West of England

Abstract

ObjectiveTo investigate student, parent/carer and secondary school staff attitudes towards school COVID-19 mitigation measures.MethodsRecruitment used school communication, community organisations and snowball sampling in South West England. Audio recorded online or phone individual/group semi-structured interviews were conducted in July–Septtember 2020 and lasted 30–60 min. Interviews focused on views towards social distancing, hand hygiene and testing. Framework analysis was performed on interview notes/transcripts.ResultsParticipants were 15 staff, 20 parents and 17 students (11–16 years) from 14 diverse schools. Concerns about COVID-19 risk at school, especially to vulnerable individuals, were outweighed by perceived risks of missed learning. Some staff felt guilt around being a potential ‘spreader’ by teaching multiple classes. Findings highlighted a wide variety of school COVID-19 mitigation measures being deployed due to ambiguous government guidance. Participants generally saw mitigation measures as an acceptable and pragmatic solution to the perceived impossibility of social distancing in crowded schools, although anticipated challenges changing habitual behaviour. Participants supported school COVID-19 testing but identified the need to consider data security and stigma around COVID-19 diagnosis. Staff were concerned about unintended consequences of risk-reduction strategies on student behaviour, learning and pastoral care, particularly for those with Special Educational Needs or mental health issues who may find the measures especially challenging, and resultant widening inequalities.ConclusionFamilies and staff supported COVID-19 mitigation measures in schools and would welcome the roll out school COVID-19 testing. Clear messaging and engendering collective responsibility are important for compliance and success of COVID-19 mitigation measures. However, schools and policy-makers should consider unintended consequences of measures, providing extra support for vulnerable students and those with additional needs, and consider ways to avoid widening educational and health inequalities. Findings demonstrate the acceptability of school COVID-19 infection control measures is likely to be influenced by the balance of risks and benefits to students.

'Like brushing teeth' - Implementation experiences with opt-in, at-home screening for SARS-CoV-2 among schoolchildren in Germany

“…[18] The high acceptance of screening expressed by our participants mirrors qualitative evidence regarding the acceptance of broader COVID-19 prevention measures in schools in the UK. [7] We expand on this evidence by highlighting the acceptability and feasibility of home-based nasal sampling among primary school pupils.…”

“…However, the idea of large-scale screening efforts at schools was criticized both from an epidemiological perspective (regarding imperfect test performance, especially of RDTs), but also as being an unnecessary burden for school children. [4][5][6] While a study from Great Britain suggests that SARS-CoV-2 protective measures in schools are highly accepted among students and parents, [7] to the best of our knowledge there is no evidence available on the perceptions of and experiences with the implementation of testing for entrance screening in school settings and the effects on compliance with other safety measures (e.g., masks).…”

From crisis to opportunity: parents and schools can come together to prioritise student health and well-being

“…From crisis to opportunity: parents and schools can come together to prioritise student health and well-being Christopher Bonell , 1 Neisha Sundaram, 1 Russell M Viner 2…”

“…In countries such as the UK where school closures have not been so extended, parents supported school closures but reported that loss of education for their children was a major concern. 1 Parents strongly supported the return to school in spring 2021 citing concerns about their children's loss of learning and well-being while not in school. 2 In US research, parents commented on their concerns for students' social and emotional development while not in school.…”

Feasibility and acceptability of daily testing at school as an alternative to self-isolation following close contact with a confirmed case of COVID-19: A qualitative analysis

“…Previous research suggests that staff, students and parents are concerned about perceived risks of missed learning [8], and that these concerns may outweigh concerns about transmission of the virus.…”