“…However, Valetich et al (2022), demonstrated large regional-scale variations in REE content of Cambrian phosphorites of the Georgina Basin: In this case, the authors proposed links between phosphorite REE content and the composition of the basement lithology and resulting in groundwater input into marine basins. Other studies have demonstrated systematic variations in total REE concentrations in seawater with depth (Alibo & Nozaki, 1999;Elderfield & Greaves, 1982;Osborne et al, 2015), while continental run-off, atmospheric input, bottom sediment flux and groundwater discharge are also known to influence the concentration, ratios and isotopic signatures of REE in oceans and coastal waters (Abbott et al, 2015;Buccione et al, 2021;Johannesson et al, 2017;Lacan et al, 2012;Molina-Kescher et al, 2018). Furthermore, REE concentrations in phosphorites can vary up to orders of magnitude even between individual layers of a deposit or between textural types ("pelletal" grainstones vs. "non-pelletal" microcrystalline carbonate fluorapatite mudstone -microsphorite) (Auer et al, 2017;Cook, 1972;Valetich et al, 2022;Watkins et al, 1995).…”