Reframing the Catholic Understanding of Just War: Two Contrasting Approaches in the Interwar Period

Abstract

During the inter war period, European Catholic authors exhibited two different approaches to the question of just war. One approach was articulated at the “Fribourg Conventus,” a 1931 meeting of French, Swiss, and German theologians, whose subsequent declaration (Conventus de bello, published in 1932) called for a reformulation of Catholic teaching based on the premise that the traditional just‐war doctrine had been superseded by developments in international law. A competing approach was articulated by the Dutch Jesuit Robert Regout, who maintained that the just‐war doctrine could contribute to the formation of international law by providing a much‐needed normative foundation for the use of armed force by individual states in redress of their violated rights. After presenting these two approaches and explaining how they differ, this essay shows how the outlook of the Conventus de bello is reflected in subsequent papal statements on armed force—to the detriment of the traditional terminology of just war.

Reflecting and Advancing the Transformation: Catholic Theological Ethics and the Journal of Religious Ethics, 1973–2023

“…Looking at 2018 onwards, by contrast, the Board of Trustees includes M. Cathleen Kaveny, Lisa Sowle Cahill, and Aline Kalbian, and the Class of 2024 Editorial Board includes MT Dávila, Linda Hogan, Stephen Pope, and Cristina Traína. Authors working in and on the Catholic moral tradition published in volumes from 2018 onwards include Nichole Flores on human trafficking (2018a), Katie Grimes on race (2018), Gregory Reichberg on just war (2018), Jean Porter on eudaimonism (2019), Grimes on just war (2019), Kenneth Himes and Paul Weithman addressing the new inequality (2019), Michael Lawler and Todd Salzman on the ethical bicameral brain (2020), as well as Darlene Fozard Weaver, Tobias Winright, and Flores on mercy (2020). In 2018, there were also focus issues on Laudato si ’ featuring Alexandre Martins, Pablo Blanco, and Flores, on Catholic sexual ethics featuring Kalbian, Elizabeth Antus, Meghan McCabe, and Traína, as well as a Book Discussion showcasing Kaveny's 2016 ground‐breaking Prophecy Without Contempt Religious Discourse in the Public Square .…”

Just War, Pacifism, Just Peace, and Peacebuilding

“…He believes this view, by severely restricting legitimate defense and anticipating the displacement of just war by "international policing," detrimentally eroded traditional just war terminology in subsequent papal statements. 90 Yet, he agrees, papal teaching does encourage restraint of arms, and "the higher efficacy and moral superiority of nonviolence" (John Paul II). 91…”