Regional Differences in Information Privacy Concerns After the Facebook-Cambridge Analytica Data Scandal

Abstract

While there is increasing global attention to data privacy, most of their current theoretical understanding is based on research conducted in a few countries. Prior work argues that people's cultural backgrounds might shape their privacy concerns; thus, we could expect people from different world regions to conceptualize them in diverse ways. We collected and analyzed a large-scale dataset of tweets about the #CambridgeAnalytica scandal in Spanish and English to start exploring this hypothesis. We employed word embeddings and qualitative analysis to identify which information privacy concerns are present and characterize language and regional differences in emphasis on these concerns. Our results suggest that related concepts, such as regulations, can be added to current information privacy frameworks. We also observe a greater emphasis on data collection in English than in Spanish. Additionally, data from North America exhibits a narrower focus on awareness compared to other regions under study. Our results call for more diverse sources of data and nuanced analysis of data privacy concerns around the globe.

The Illusion of Artificial Inclusion

“…When the underlying attitudes and conventions shift, an LLM does not update itself to encode new norms: the responses it generates will still reflect attitudes from the time when it was trained. An LLM trained on data before 2018, for instance, would not predict the shift in privacy concerns among social media users following March of that year [56,77]. Much like the constraints imposed by hallucination, value lock-in challenges the accuracy of substitution, and therefore weakens the arguments focused on efficiency and financial benefits.…”

Linked by age: a study on social media privacy concerns among younger and older adults

“…Other work on privacy concerns on social media has either employed conceptualizations that we consider partial, examining only a subset of the social media privacy concerns dimensions previously presented (e.g. González-Pizarro et al ., 2022), similar ones (e.g. access, misuse and dissemination of information: Ayaburi and Treku, 2020), or used the more general construct of Internet privacy concerns (e.g.…”