Objective: Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) share inhibitory control deficits possibly underlying poor control over stereotyped/repetitive and compulsive behaviours, respectively. However, it is unclear whether these symptom profiles are mediated by common or distinct neural profiles. This comparative multimodal meta-analysis assessed shared and disorder-specific neuroanatomy and neurofunction of inhibitory functions.
Methods:A comparative meta-analysis of 62 voxel-based morphometry (VBM) and 26 functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies of inhibitory control was conducted comparing grey matter volume (GMV) and activation abnormalities between ASD (sMRI:911;fMRI:188) and OCD (sMRI:928;fMRI:247) patients versus controls. Multimodal meta-analysis compared groups across VBM and fMRI.Results: Both disorders shared reduced function and structure in rostral/dorsomedial prefrontal cortex including anterior cingulate. OCD had disorder-specific increase in structure and function of left basal ganglia (BG)/insula relative to controls and ASD, who had reduced right BG/insula volumes versus OCD. In fMRI, ASD patients showed disorder-specific reduced left dorsolateral-prefrontal activation and reduced posterior cingulate deactivation, while OCD patients showed temporoparietal underactivation.
Conclusions:The multimodal comparative meta-analysis shows shared and disorder-specific abnormalities. While rostro-dorsomedial prefrontal cortex was smaller in structure and function in both disorders, this was concomitant with increased structure and function in BG/insula in OCD, but a reduction in ASD, presumably reflecting a disorder-specific fronto-striato-insular dysregulation in OCD in the form of poor frontal control over overactive BG, and a fronto-striato-insular maldevelopment in ASD with reduced structure and function in this network. Disorder-differential mechanisms appear to drive overlapping phenotypes of inhibitory control abnormalities in ASD and OCD.
Carlisi et al.3