“…However, for mudrock-hosted, opening-mode fractures that are isolated from faults, the preponderance of evidence supports closed-system fluid behaviour. This evidence includes (i) fill textures indicating that cement kept up with fracture opening (i.e., fibrous fill), so that the fracture was never particularly porous throughout growth (Hilgers et al, 2001); (ii) fill mineralogy and fracture intensity that both vary sensitively with the local stratigraphy (Franks, 1969;Hooker et al, 2017a), suggesting that fracture propagation and fluid flow produced little cross-stratal migration; (iii) isotope geochemistry of fracture and host-rock minerals (Hooker et al, 2017b), whose correspondence generally supports a low-fluid, rock-buffered environment of fracturing; (iv) blunt tips, such that the fracture aperture decays rapidly beyond the end of the median zone, implying little propagation during widening (Meng, 2017a); and (v) a timing that commonly predates significant tectonic deformation (Foreman and Dunne, 1991;Maher et al, 2016;Ukar et al, 2017), during which fluids commonly advect (Evans and Fischer, 2012). Gasparrini et al, 2013;c: Heimhofer et al, 2016;d: Hooker et al, 2017b;e: Hudson et al, 2001;f: Li et al, 2013;g: Meng et al, 2017a;h: Parnell et al, 2013;i: Yu et al, 2015;j: Zhang et al, 2016. Hudson et al, 2001;b: de Haller et al, 2011;c: Gasparrini et al, 2013;d: Li et al, 2013;e: Parnell et al, 2013;f: Yu et al, 2015;g: Heimhofer et al, 2016;h: Zhang et al, 2016;i: Hooker et al, 2017b;j: Meng et al, 2017a.…”