Using the Al I precursor Cp 3t Al in conjunction with triphosphiranes (PAr) 3 (Ar = Mes,Dip,Tip) we have succeeded in preparing Lewis base-free cyclic diphosphadialanes with both the Al and Patoms bearing three substituents.U sing the sterically more demanding Dip and Tips ubstituents the first 1,2-diphospha-3,4-dialuminacyclobutanes were obtained, whereas with Mes substituents [Cp 3t Al(m-PMes)] 2 is formed. This divergent reactivity was corroborated by DFT studies, which indicated the thermodynamic preference for the 1,2diphospha-3,4-dialuminacyclobutane form for sterically more demanding groups on phosphorus.U sing Cp*Al we could extend this concept to the corresponding cyclic diarsadialanes [Cp*Al(m-AsAr)] 2 (Ar = Dip,T ip) and additionally add the phosphorus variants [Cp*Al(m-PAr)] 2 (P = Mes,D ip,T ip). The reactivity of one variant [Cp 3t Al(m-PPh)] 2 towards NHCs was tested and resulted in double NHC-stabilised [Cp 3t -(IiPr 2 )Al(m-PPh)] 2 .